On
Rotten Tomatoes it has a 31% rating based on reviews from 13 critics.
Siskel and Ebert gave the film two thumbs up on a 1997 episode of their
program. They praised the crude humor, comparing it to
Beavis and Butt-head. Leonard Klady of
Variety labelled it "oddly effective", and said "a mixed bag of street humor, broad, bawdy jokes and
hip-hop music, the film is very much on target to score a bull’s-eye with
African-American auds." A mixed review at the time came from Mike D'Angelo of
Entertainment Weekly who gave it a C rating. D'Angelo wrote, "no,
Booty Call has nothing to do with pirates and their ill-gotten gain. Then again, maybe there is: Two modern-day swashbucklers (Jamie Foxx and Tommy Davidson) yearn to plunder two willing maidens (Vivica A. Fox and Tamala Jones), but first they have to locate a couple of sheaths for their swords, if you know what I mean." D'Angelo went on to write, "most of the time, the amiable foursome is left ambling aimlessly from one so-so sketch concept to the next: four characters in search of a comedy." Bruce Walker of
The Washington Post also had a mixed review, writing, "the name is enough to clue you in that this is not highbrow humor. In fact, it will appeal mostly to those who can appreciate basic juvenile humor." He added, "the movie seems more like a series of skits, some of which work and some of which don't." In a 1997 interview with
Charlie Rose, black actor and filmmaker
Charles S. Dutton criticized young African-Americans who went to see
Booty Call rather than the historical drama
Rosewood, which was released around the same time. It was later referenced in a 1999 episode of
The Simpsons titled
Beyond Blunderdome, where a film executive character labels a fictitious
director's cut of
Booty Call as "fabulous". ==References==