The book received predominantly favorable reviews, with some exceptions. In
The Guardian,
Jude Rogers wrote "Complex, quick-witted and stack-full of raw talent: this isn't how people like to see
Carly Simon. After all, [Simon] was also the long-legged, hyena-mouthed lover of many famous men (
William Donaldson, writer of the Henry Root letters,
Kris Kristofferson,
Mick Jagger and
Jack Nicholson, for starters), and the wayward daughter of a publishing icon
Richard, the Simon of
Simon & Schuster. These boys in the trees, and many more, follow her, dog her and haunt her. Her process of shaking them free forms the foundations of this brilliant memoir." Similarly, in
The Independent, Fiona Sturges found
Boys in the Trees a "hugely affecting memoir", describing Simon's recounting "as, for the most part, heartfelt and remarkable in [its] detail...Similarly impressive is the fearlessness, frankness and wisdom with which she chronicles half a lifetime of pain." In 2016,
Billboard ranked the book No. 50 on list of the 100 Greatest Music Books of All Time. ==References==