The bill received broad cross-party welcome, though with significant disagreements on implementation timing and scope. The
Congress proposed an unsuccessful amendment to implement the reservation by 2024.
Swami Prasad Maurya of
Samajwadi Party termed the bill "flawed" for lacking OBC reservation.
Nitish Kumar, Chief Minister of
Bihar, questioned the delayed implementation timeline.
Yogendra Yadav argued implementation would not occur until 2039, calling the legislation "trickery." Both the ruling party and opposition claimed credit for advancing the legislation.
Criticism The legislation has faced structured criticism on several grounds: ;Implementation Delay:Critics argue that linking the reservation to a post-2026 delimitation effectively postpones its effect by several electoral cycles. Opposition parties and analysts, such as
Yogendra Yadav, have termed this linkage a "delay tactic." Projections suggest that the quota may not be implemented until the 2029 or 2034 elections. ;Exclusion of OBC and Minority Quotas:Political parties including the
Indian National Congress,
Samajwadi Party, and
Rashtriya Janata Dal have criticised the absence of sub-reservation for women from
Other Backward Classes (OBC) and religious minorities. They argue that without such sub-quotas, the legislation will disproportionately benefit urban and upper-caste women. The only two votes against the Bill in the Lok Sabha came from
All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen MPs who demanded these inclusions. ;Omission of Upper Houses:The reservation applies only to the Lok Sabha and State Assemblies. Critics note that the omission of the
Rajya Sabha and State Legislative Councils creates a representation gap in the upper chambers of Indian legislatures. ;Rotation Mechanism:The mandatory rotation of reserved seats after each delimitation has raised concerns about the continuity of representation and the potential for "proxy" candidatures, where male relatives of women candidates wield actual power. Opponents of this view argue that rotation prevents the permanent exclusion of male candidates from specific constituencies. ==Following legislations==