Reviews of the film were mixed. Positive reviewers included
Mick LaSalle of the
San Francisco Chronicle, who thought that the film was "an audacious attempt actually to make them like they used to - with no apologies, no nostalgia. It's no masterpiece, but neither was every Marx Brothers movie." In her review for
The New York Times,
Janet Maslin wrote, "
Brain Donors will stop at very little to get its laughs, and Mr. Turturro has just the right silliness for the occasion." A positive review in the
South Florida Sun-Sentinel noted, "It doesn't have one believable, well-rounded character, it doesn't appeal to our nobler emotions, and it doesn't have anything politically correct to say about any important social problems. These seeming faults, however, are exactly the qualities that make it the most hilarious film yet this year." Other reviews were less enthusiastic, especially in comparison to the original Marx Brothers films and to the prior films on which the Zucker brothers had worked. Richard Harrington in his review for
The Washington Post wrote, "It's all very busy, and in Zucker style there seem to be 10 jokes per minute, but most fly fast and fall flat." Pamela Bruce, writing for the
Austin Chronicle, believed the film was too derivative of the Marx Brothers and the
Three Stooges, and thought the
claymation sequences that bookend the film were more interesting than the actual movie itself. The
Los Angeles Daily News described it as "Impudent and manic, yes, in the best Marxian tradition. But it is desperate in its scattered shots at any lame thing for a possible laugh, where the Marxes were always cool and -- for the most part -- surreally inspired when it came to stringing nonsense together." Malcolm Johnson of the
Hartford Courant called it a "sometimes clever but ultimately exhausting farce" and noted perplexedly that its title had nothing to do with its subject matter.
Variety gave a negative review, remarking, "The title Brain Donors sounds like a horror film and for those expecting a comedy, it is."
Entertainment Weekly called it "an almost total failure" and thought "the cheesy sets and breathless pacing give the film the feel of a made-for-TV movie on amphetamines." A 2005 reevaluation of screenwriter
Pat Proft's work wrote approvingly of
Brain Donors, remarking, "as a throwback to the Marx/
Ritz Brothers ideal of
Hellzapoppin' humor, it tried to recapture the bygone days of slapstick and satire, and actually did a terrific job at both." ==References==