Critical response ,
Jonathan Cavendish,
Andrew Garfield,
Claire Foy and Diana Cavendish Upon release, the film received generally mixed reviews. On
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an approval rating of 67%, based on 166 reviews and a
weighted average of 6.4/10. The site's critical consensus reads, "Strong performances from
Breathes well-matched leads help add an edge to a biopic that takes a decidedly heartwarming approach to its real-life story." On
Metacritic, the film holds a weighted average score of 51 out of 100, based on 29 critics, indicating "mixed or average" reviews.
Mark Kermode, writing in
The Guardian, gave the film four out of five stars, praising
Andrew Garfield's portrayal of Robin Cavendish: "There's real terror in Garfield's eyes as Robin stares into the abyss, spitting in the face of a hospital chaplain who announces that his suffering is somehow part of God's great plan". Kermode also gave praise to the film's score, and the role of Diana Cavendish's twin brothers, portrayed in a dual role by
Tom Hollander.
The New York Times writer Jeannette Catsoulis gave a mixed review, stating that the film's true purpose "is smothered by a cloying fairy tale romance that turns every challenge the couple faces into a lark". She went on to praise the actors, but stated that they were held back by the script: "Mr. Garfield smiles broadly through episodes of near-suffocation and bloody sputum, while Ms. Foy embodies the buck-up-and-carry-on mentality that William Nicholson's screenplay demands". Of the main cast, he stated that "
Breathe paints them as borderline saints, flattening their humanity and carefully glossing over potentially tricky subjects, notably sexual matters. Foy's performance, perky with a hint of steel, mostly rises above these limitations. But Garfield is inevitably hampered by a role that restricts him to little more than nodding and grinning. Tom Hollander also does double duty as Diana's twin brothers, his dual role seemingly an excuse for some creaky comic banter and slick visual effects". He also praised the cast, specifically Garfield, who "climbs wholeheartedly into the role of Robin and delivers a convincing performance despite only having his face to act with".
The Sydney Morning Herald writer
Sandra Hall agreed that the movie is one of the "cheeriest", and "there are times when the film's unassailable optimism gets in the way of its credibility".
Los Angeles Times writer Robert Abele called the film a "clichéd execution", noting that "Garfield and Foy, tasked with packing a whole marriage into one film, easily convey the attractiveness of being an indomitable team, but rarely get to plumb the depths of anything else".
Accolades ==Notes==