He decided to enter the priesthood, attempting first to enter
St Stephen's House, Oxford, but was refused, instead entering
Ely Theological College. He was ordained deacon in 1962 and priest in 1963, and served his title at St Andrew's,
Clewer (1962–67). In 1967 he was appointed Vicar of Holy Trinity in Reading, which he transformed into an ornate centre of Anglo-Catholic worship. He was likewise known for his eccentric and flamboyant personal style, as one obituary described: "He wore his grey curly hair in a style resembling a periwig and dressed in lavish Roman monsignoral attire, including buckled shoes with four-inch heels, which he had painted red." The architectural historian
Gavin Stamp described Holy Trinity as a "dull Gothic box"; but it was one which Brindley greatly enlivened. The
chancel screen in the church was designed by
Augustus Pugin and had originally been installed in
St Chad's Cathedral in
Birmingham. It escaped destruction and Brindley rescued and installed it. The chancel screen is the reason for the church being listed. The chancel screen was merely the most prominent of the treasures that Brindley acquired. Other items included a
Martin Travers high altar (in the form of a gilded sarcophagus), designed for
Nashdom Abbey, which Brindley installed in the Lady chapel. The pulpit was rescued from
All Saints Church, Oxford when it was converted to
Lincoln College's Library. From the same source came Sir
Thomas Graham Jackson's gilded lectern. The high altar was rescued from
St Paul's, Walton Street, Oxford, complete with its 17th-century
tabernacle, which had itself been rescued from a Belgian church in the
First World War. The Church's
General Synod was established in 1970. Brindley unsuccessfully sought election on that occasion, but successfully so at the following election in 1975, and remained a vocal and prominent Anglo-Catholic member of Synod until his fall from grace. In 1985 he was made an
honorary canon of
Christ Church Cathedral, Oxford. In the summer of 1989, the
News of the World published a front-page article which incorporated a secretly recorded conversation in which Brindley fantasized about young men. After two evangelical members of Synod circulated photocopies of the tabloid's front page to all 500 members, Brindley resigned from Synod, the canonry, and his parish.
Eric Kemp,
Bishop of Chichester, offered him the position of Diocesan Pastoral Secretary in the
Diocese of Chichester. ==Conversion==