Mueller was drafted by the
Hartford Whalers after a successful season of junior hockey and began attending
Clarkson University the following fall. He arrived in
Potsdam immediately after the Golden Knights' run to the frozen four, adding depth to the team as a freshman. Over the winter break, Mueller was also selected as a member of
Team USA for the
1992 World Junior Championships. While he went scoreless in 7 games, he was part of the defensive corps that shut down opponents for 5 wins and enabled the US to win the
bronze medal, just the second medal the team had earned in the 16-year history of the tournament. For his sophomore season Mueller increased his point total and helped the Golden Knights win the
conference tournament. unfortunately, for the second straight year, Clarkson flamed out in the opening round of the
NCAA Tournament. In his first two seasons Mueller had been a stable defender for the Golden Knights but he turned into an offensive dynamo during his junior year. He finished second in the nation for scoring by defensemen and was named an All-American. Unfortunately for Mueller, Clarkson lost in the conference semifinal and ended up getting left out of the national tournament. Mueller nearly repeated his offensive production as a senior but was able to help the team finish atop
ECAC Hockey. Clarkson was again felled in the semifinal but they were able to secure a bid to the
1995 NCAA Tournament. The Golden Knights got a home game for the opening round, however, they were set against defending champion
Lake Superior State. While the Lakers weren't as good as the year before, they were battle tested and the team managed to fight back against Clarkson and win a hard-fought road game 5–4. After graduating, Mueller began his professional career spending most of his first two seasons with the
Springfield Falcons. He headed to
Europe in 1997 and spent most of the year with
HPK before returning to
North America. Mueller rounded out his career with a parts of two seasons in lower-level minor leagues and retired in 2000. After his playing days were over, Mueller turned to coaching, working with junior players in Michigan Wisconsin and Illinois. He was named Vice President of Hockey operations for a program in the
Chicago area and led teams to two national junior championships in 2012 and 2016. After the second title, Mueller was hired by the
Pittsburgh Penguins as a head coach and
executive director of the
UPMC Lemieux Sports Complex Hockey Academy and continues to work in that role as of 2021. ==Statistics==