Box office According to MGM records the film earned $1,982,000 in the US and Canada and $1,293,000 and resulted in a loss of $1,555,000.
Variety posted a lukewarm review, calling the dance staging "not particularly arresting, although a few of the numbers will have a desired effect on the audience, and the vocals fail to give the tunes the tonal impact needed to put them over." ''
Harrison's Reports'' wrote of the film: "It has much to recommend it from the viewpoint of the production values, and there are individual musical sequences that are nimble, gay, and cheery, but some of the other production numbers are long, drawn out, and tedious, and on the whole the picture's fantasy theme misfires."
John McCarten of
The New Yorker wrote: "There are times in this version of 'Brigadoon' when one is seized by the wild hope that the exposition of the town's dilemma will be quickly boiled down to an essence, so that Gene Kelly and Cyd Charisse can get on with their dancing. The problems of the community are always getting in the way though ... I rather regretted that they weren't able to cut loose with their musical paces more often."
The Monthly Film Bulletin called the film "a sizeable disappointment. Overloaded with Hollywood-Scottish trappings, with tartans, bagpipes and a wedding celebration preceded by a miniature sort of gathering of the clans, the tenuous romantic fantasy is slackly developed ... and the whimsical dream-world it creates holds no compelling attractions."
Leonard Maltin in his reappraisal feels this adaptation was unfairly overlooked when it first appeared and particularly praises the "lovely" score, orchestrated mainly by
Conrad Salinger, and the performance of
Van Johnson as Jeff Douglas. On the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 75% based on 16 reviews.
Accolades The film was nominated for three
Academy Awards in 1955: • Best Art Direction-Set Decoration, Color – (
Cedric Gibbons,
E. Preston Ames,
Edwin B. Willis,
F. Keogh Gleason) • Best Costume Design, Color – (
Irene Sharaff) • Best Sound, Recording –
Wesley C. Miller (MGM) The film won a 1955
Golden Globe: • Best Cinematography, Color – (Joseph Ruttenberg) ==See also==