"Brokedown Palace" was included as the second track on the second side of the
American Beauty record. And is seen as a highlight on the album as well as one of the band's best songs and ballads. When ranking the 20 best Grateful Dead songs for
Paste magazine, Matt Mitchell placed it at number 18, calling it "sublime and gentle", while noting that "it’s saccharine in a way that the band just never gets hit in the same way ever again." he concludes by saying that he personally prefers the track as a "tender, solemn moment of farewell and of soul’s set adrift." Various writers of Rolling Stone placed it at 46 in a ranking of Jerry Garcia's 50 greatest songs, Stating that "Garcia paired Hunter’s lyrics about letting go with a dollop of Southern gospel, heightened by the Dead’s woodsy harmonies" Writing for Pitchfork Andy Cush called it an "uncomfortably intimate window on their process, which hardly anyone needs to hear more than once." == Personnel ==