DHA-based products DHA (
dihydroxyacetone, also known as glycerone) is not a dye, stain or paint, but causes a chemical reaction with the
amino acids in the dead layer on the skin surface. One of the pathways is a free radical-mediated Maillard reaction. The other pathway is the conventional
Maillard reaction, a process well known to food chemists that causes the browning that occurs during food manufacturing and storage. It does not involve the underlying
skin pigmentation nor does it require exposure to
ultraviolet light to initiate the color change. However, for the 24 hours after self-tanner is applied, the skin is especially susceptible to ultraviolet, according to a 2007 study led by Katinka Jung of the Gematria Test Lab in Berlin. Forty minutes after the researchers treated skin samples with high levels of DHA they found that more than 180 percent additional free radicals formed during sun exposure compared with untreated skin. Another self-tanner ingredient,
erythrulose, produced a similar response at high levels. For a day after self-tanner application, excessive sun exposure should be avoided and sunscreen should be worn outdoors, they say; an antioxidant cream could also minimize free radical production. Although some self-tanners contain sunscreen, its effect will not last long after application, and a fake tan itself will not protect the skin from UV exposure. The study by Jung et al. further confirms earlier results demonstrating that dihydroxyacetone in combination with dimethylisosorbide enhances the process of (sun-based) tanning. This earlier study also found that dihydroxyacetone also has an effect on the amino acids and nucleic acids which is bad for the skin. The free radicals are due to the action of UV light on AGE (
advanced glycation end-products) as a result of the reaction of DHA with the skin, and the intermediates, such as
Amadori products (a type of AGE), that lead to them. AGEs are behind the damage to the skin that occurs with high blood sugar in diabetes where similar glycation occurs. AGEs absorb and provide a little protection against some of the damaging factors of UV (up to SPF 3), However, they do not have melanin's extended electronic structure that dissipates the energy, so part of it goes towards starting free radical chain reactions instead, in which other AGEs participate readily. Overall tanner enhances free radical injury. There may also be some inhibition of vitamin D production in DHA-treated skin. The color effect is temporary and fades gradually over 3 to 10 days. Some of these products also use
erythrulose which works identically to DHA, but develops more slowly. Both DHA and erythrulose have been known to cause
contact dermatitis. Professional spray tan applications are available from spas, salons and gymnasiums by both hand-held sprayers and in the form of sunless or UV-Free spray booths. Spray tan applications are also available through online retail distribution channels and are widely available to purchase for in home use. The enclosed booth, which resembles an enclosed shower stall, sprays the tanning solution over the entire body. The U.S.
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) states when using DHA-containing products as an all-over spray or mist in a commercial spray "tanning" booth, it may be difficult to avoid exposure in a manner for which DHA is not approved, including the area of the eyes, lips, or mucous membrane, or even internally. DHA is not approved by the FDA for inhalation. issued by the
European Commission's Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety, concluding spray tanning with DHA did not pose risk, has been heavily criticized by specialists. This is because the cosmetics industry in Europe chose the evidence to review, according to the commission itself. Thus, nearly every report the commission's eventual opinion referenced came from studies that were never published or peer-reviewed and, in the majority of cases, were performed by companies or industry groups linked to the manufacturing of DHA. The industry left out nearly all of the peer-reviewed studies published in publicly available scientific journals that identified DHA as a potential mutagen. A study by scientists from the Department of Dermatology, Bispebjerg Hospital, published in
Mutation Research has concluded DHA 'induces DNA damage, cell-cycle block and apoptosis' in cultured cells.
SIK-inhibitors A novel class of compounds has been found to stimulate
melanogenesis in a mechanism that is independent from
α-melanocyte-stimulating hormone (α-MSH) activation of the
melanocortin 1 receptor (MC1 receptor). This is accomplished via small molecule inhibition of salt-inducible kinases (SIK). Inhibition of SIK increases transcription of MITF which is known to increase
melanin production. Work published in June 2017 has demonstrated compounds that have efficacy when applied topically to human skin. These compounds are still however in pre-clinical stages of development. Future directions may include the incorporation of SIK-inhibitor compounds with traditional UV-blocking sunscreens to minimize UV-related DNA damage in the short term while providing longer term protection through endogenous melanin production.
Tyrosine-based products Tanning accelerators—lotions or pills that usually contain the amino acid
tyrosine—claim that they stimulate and increase
melanin formation, thereby accelerating the tanning process. These are used in conjunction with UV exposure. At this time, there is no scientific data available to support these claims.
Melanotan peptide hormones The role of
alpha-melanocyte-stimulating hormone (α-MSH) in promoting melanin diffusion has been known since the 1960s. In the 1980s, scientists at University of Arizona began attempting to develop α-MSH and analogs as potential sunless tanning agents, and synthesized and tested several analogs, including
afamelanotide, then called melanotan-I. Afamelanotide is also being investigated as a method of
photoprotection from in the treatment of
polymorphous light eruption,
actinic keratosis and
squamous cell carcinoma (a form of
skin cancer).
Bremelanotide is used for the treatment of generalized
hypoactive sexual desire disorder (HSDD) in premenopausal women. To pursue the tanning agent, melanotan-I was licensed by Competitive Technologies, a
technology transfer company operating on behalf of University of Arizona, to an Australian startup called Epitan, which changed its name to Clinuvel in 2006. A number of products are sold online and in gyms and beauty salons as "melanotan" or "melanotan-1" which discuss afamelanotide in their marketing. The products are not legal in any jurisdiction and are dangerous. Starting in 2007 health agencies in various counties began issuing warnings against their use.
Other melanogenesis stimulants Eicosanoids,
retinoids,
oestrogens,
melanocyte-stimulating hormone,
endothelins,
psoralens,
hydantoin,
forskolin,
cholera toxin,
isobutylmethylxanthine,
diacylglycerol analogues, and UV irradiation all trigger melanogenesis and, in turn, pigmentation. ==Temporary bronzers (skin colorants)==