At the time of its release,
Brother was hyped as Kitano's vehicle for breaking into the United States film market. The film has a 47% rating on
Rotten Tomatoes based on 74 reviews, and an average rating of 5.2/10. The website's critical consensus states: "There is too much hollow bloodshed in
Brother, and the characters are stereotypically flat".
Metacritic assigned the film a weighted average score of 47 out of 100, based on 23 critics, indicating "mixed or average" reviews.
Roger Ebert, who has praised all of Kitano's films he has seen, complimented Kitano in his review but ultimately rated the film two out of four stars, writing that "
Brother is a typical Kitano film in many ways, but not one of his best ones." Marc Savlov of the
Austin Chronicle gave the film two and half stars out of five, stating: "Kitano's beat is an altogether grimmer affair, laden with dark irony and unexpurgated scenes of violence. It's rougher stuff than most would expect, though not unrewarding in its own horrific way." A reviewer of
Time Out commented: "A film of almost diagrammatic clarity, in which questions of loyalty, honour and, yes, brotherhood are mere pieces on the chessboard." In his review for
Variety, David Rooney wrote: "Kitano frequently tips his hat to the American gangster movie in Coppola-styled scenes of confrontation and carnage. But while many of the action set pieces are enlivened by the director’s customary verve and humor, the plot advances clumsily with the narrative engine continually sputtering and stopping. Characters are so unsatisfyingly developed that the film delivers only on a basic level as a tale of gangster rivalry, greed, elimination and expansion, with its larger themes struggling to register...
Brother is full of elegant compositions and poised, deliberate camera movement but rarely matches the visual impact of earlier Kitano features."
Response from Takeshi Kitano Kitano stated in an interview that he was not fully satisfied with the final result of
Brother and that he regretted his "Hollywood" adventure, which was supposed to bring him a broader audience with a higher exposure. Kitano said he had no intention of shooting outside Japan again. == References ==