In 1954, Alger became the Republican candidate for
U.S. House of Representatives for
Texas's 5th congressional district. Considering his state's Democratic tradition, it was unexpected that Alger would win. He received 27,982 ballots (52.9 percent) to Democrat
Wallace H. Savage's 24,904 (47.1 percent). He was the only Republican in the Texas delegation for eight years until 1963, when
Ed Foreman of
Odessa, later of Dallas, joined Alger for the final two years of his tenure. Alger served during the heyday of the
Lyndon B. Johnson and
Sam Rayburn era. As a Republican, and a strongly
conservative Republican at that, he was the odd man out in the Texas delegation of the day. Alger considered himself an individualist, a
constitutionalist, and a man of principles. Critics, however, equated his principles to stubbornness. His belief in
limited government conflicted with many of his colleagues, who expected to trade for votes on various issues and projects, something he refused to do. In the era of
civil rights, he believed that solutions lay with local, not national government. He maintained that the national government should concentrate on defense and foreign affairs. He believed that the responsibility for social programs belonged at the local level. He was the only member of the House, for example, to oppose the popular
school lunch program. Despite being in the majority of the Texas delegation to decline to sign the 1956
Southern Manifesto opposing the desegregation of public schools ordered by the Supreme Court in
Brown v. Board of Education, Alger voted against the
Civil Rights Acts of 1957,
1960, and
1964, as well as the
24th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. According to
Time magazine (January 6, 1958), Alger assessed the upcoming second session of the Democratic 85th Congress in a pessimistic but resolved vein: "I foresee bitterness and hatefulness... We are going to squabble and fight and make the world think we hate each other and that we can't solve our problems. We are going to have bigger and bigger budgets, higher taxes, more government spending at home and abroad, and more
inflation accompanied by deficit financing. Happy New Year!" and her white gloves were yanked from her and thrown into a gutter. Vice President
Richard M. Nixon believed that the "Mink Coat Mob" incident caused him to
lose Texas's then twenty-four electoral votes to Kennedy and Johnson. Columnists
Rowland Evans and
Robert Novak said that the protest also affected the votes of white southerners in other states. Nixon later said, "Well, we lost Texas in 1960 because of that a**hole congressman in Dallas". ==Defeated for reelection, 1964==