Fogarty began playing hockey as a young boy. His sister Lynn says "I think [hockey] was hard-wired into our [family's] veins." His older brother played
street hockey and Lynn says he thought "I want to be like those big kids and I want to be out there and I'm going to play." Brantford Minor Hockey Association coordinator Bob Coyne said that Fogarty's hockey skills were apparent "from day one." Coyne compared Fogarty to
Wayne Gretzky, who had also grown up in Brantford, saying "[Gretzky's] game was outsmarting everybody else. Fogarty's game was outperforming everybody else." In the mid-to-late 1980s, Fogarty played with the
Ontario Hockey League (OHL). He was chosen first overall in the 1985 OHL draft by Ken Slater of the
Kingston Canadians, ahead of several other future NHL players, including
Adam Graves (6th),
Bryan Marchment (12th),
Brendan Shanahan (13th), and
Jody Hull (14th). Slater says Fogarty attracted a lot of attention early on, and some of his games had as many as 40 scouts in attendance — "They couldn't believe the hockey sense and the puck control." At the end of the year, Fogarty was named the Canadian major-junior player of the year. According to Max Offenburger, a sports psychologist who worked with Fogarty frequently, he once asked Thunder coach
Bill LaForge about Fogarty. LaForge responded by calling Fogarty over and making a bet with him — if Fogarty scored seven points in that night's game, he'd win ; if not, he'd take Offenburger and LaForge out to dinner. During the third
period of the game, Fogarty scored his fourth assist with teammate Keith Primeau, for a total of seven points. Afterwards, he skated over to the bench and said to LaForge, "I win. Do I have to play any more?" During his time with the Nordiques he continued to be regarded as an excellent player. Fogarty maintains the distinction of recording the last
natural hat trick in Quebec Nordiques franchise history when he scored three straight goals on December 1, 1990, in a 4–2 home win over the Sabres. He was the first Nordiques defenceman to record a hat trick. In 1999, following some legal troubles, Fogarty attempted a comeback with the
Toronto Maple Leafs' affiliate, the
St. John's Maple Leafs. He lasted 3 regular season games with them before being released. He then played two more seasons with some minor league teams, but "only as a favour to some friends" In total, he played nine seasons of pro hockey in seven leagues for 17 teams, retiring in 2001. ==Personal life==