Early career Fowler first played for a largely white professional team based out of
New Castle, Pennsylvania, in 1872, when he was 14 years old. He is documented as playing for another professional team on July 21, 1877, when he was 19. On May 17, 1878, while playing for the
Lynn Live Oaks, Fowler reportedly became the first Black player in to appear in a game in organized baseball. On April 24, 1878, he pitched a game for the Picked Nine, who defeated the
Boston Red Caps, champions of the
National League in 1877. He pitched some more for the Chelsea team, then finished that season with the
Worcester club. Largely supporting himself as a barber, Fowler continued to play for baseball teams in New England and Canada for the next four years. He then moved to the Midwest. In 1883, Fowler played for a team in
Niles, Ohio; in 1884, he played for
Stillwater, Minnesota, in the
Northwestern League.
Keokuk In
Keokuk, Iowa, there had not been a professional baseball team since 1875. However, in 1885, local businessman R. W. "Nick" Curtis was the chief force behind starting a new team and hired Fowler for it. Johnny Peters, the manager of the then-disbanded Stillwater, Minnesota team, helped Fowler get connected with the new team in Keokuk, the
Keokuk Hawkeyes. Fowler became the most popular player on the Keokuk team. The local newspaper, the
Keokuk Gate City and Constitution, described him as "a good ball player, a hard worker, a genius on the ball field, intelligent, gentlemanly in his conduct and deserving of the good opinion entertained for him by base ball admirers here." Fowler also commented to the local newspaper on issues with the "reserve clause," the contractual mechanism that allowed teams to hold on to players for their entire career. Fowler stated that "when a ball player signs a league contract they can do anything with him under its provisions but hang him." The Western League folded that season due to financial reasons, leaving Keokuk without a league, and Fowler was released.
Later career Fowler moved to play with a team in
Pueblo, Colorado. In 1886, he played for a team in
Topeka, Kansas. That team won the pennant behind Fowler's .309 average. He also led the league in
triples. In 1887, Fowler moved to
Binghamton, New York and played on a team there. Racial tensions arose, and his teammates refused to continue playing with him. In 1888, he played for the
Crawfordsville Hoosiers/
Terre Haute Hoosiers. Fowler played for the 1890
Sterling Blue Coats /
Galesburg Pavers /
Burlington Hawkeyes, as the
Illinois-Iowa League franchise relocated twice. In 1892, Fowler played for
Kearney, Nebraska in the
Nebraska State League. In 1893 and 1894 he played on the integrated ballclub called the
Findlay Sluggers. In the summer of 1894 Fowler and
Home Run Johnson, along with three white businessmen, Len Hoch, Howard and Rolla Taylor, formed the
Page Fence Giants in
Adrian, Michigan. Fowler played second base for the 1895 Giants but was moved to right field when the team signed
Sol White to play that position in June 1895. Fowler apparently had a falling out with the management team and by June 1895, both Fowler and Johnson were simply referred to as salaried players and not members of the ownership group. Fowler played about another month with the Page Fence club and then finished the season with one game with the
Michigan State League member
Adrian Demons and about 30 games with another MSL team, the
Lansing Senators squad. From 1894 to 1904, Fowler played and/or managed the Page Fence Giants,
Cuban Giants, Smoky City Giants,
All-American Black Tourists, and Kansas City Stars. According to baseball historian James A. Riley, Fowler played 10 seasons of organized baseball, "a record [for an African American player] until broken by
Jackie Robinson in his last season with the
Brooklyn Dodgers." ==Later life and legacy==