The Blazers joined the NSL for the 1976 season and became the first representative from Buffalo to compete in the league. The team ownership initially applied for a franchise in the
North American Soccer League, but the Upstate New York territorial rights were held by the
Rochester Lancers. Buffalo's first home venue was at Lackwanna Stadium in the suburb of
Lackawanna, New York, where the club averaged an attendance of around 700 to 1,500 spectators. The club experienced growing pains in their initial run in the Canadian circuit as they struggled to find a suitable head coach throughout the campaign. Originally, Al Block served at the helm before being replaced by Vincent Lauricella as interim coach. Perolli led Buffalo to a fourth-place finish in the division, and club striker Emmanuel Kulu finished the campaign as the leading scorer in the division. The following season, the ownership switched their home venue to
War Memorial Stadium to avoid scheduling conflicts and to adhere to the league's stadium standards. Buffalo also secured a television deal to broadcast some of their home matches. Alex Crawley, who previously managed the
St. Catharines Heidelberg, was named the head coach for the season. The Blazers secured promotion to the league's First Division by finishing third. Buffalo struggled to achieve significant results during their run in the league's top division as they finished at the bottom of the standings. The Blazers originally had Sam Buscarino as their head coach but was later replaced by
Roberto Lonardo in the capacity of
player-coach. Midway through the 1978 season, the club owners decided to play out in the suburbs once more as their attendance numbers sharply declined since their move to War Memorial. In 1979, the league went through a period of reorganization which resulted in Buffalo taking a hiatus and operating at the amateur level. Stephen Mechtler would serve as head coach and the team would play in a series of friendly matches against NSL clubs.. In 1980, after a one-year hiatus, the Blazers continued operations in the National Soccer League and returned to play at Lackwanna Stadium. The Blazers hired Carlo Del Monte as their head coach who previously managed
Hamilton Italo-Canadians. Del Monte assembled a roster that consisted of many former Hamilton players. The acquisitions proved initially successful as Buffalo produced an undefeated streak of eight matches. Their on-field performance would later produce mediocre results due to internal strife within the organization. Following his departure, Del Monte became director of scouting in Canada for the
Buffalo Stallions. In 1981, the club ceased operations and was replaced by
Detroit Besa. == Head coach history ==