The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote:It's sad to see the talents of Vernon Sewell (he was responsible for such fine thrillers as
The Man in the Back Seat [1961] and
House of Mystery [1961]) being frittered away on a project as incoherent as this one. Unlike John Gilling's excellent treatment of the same subject in
The Flesh and the Fiends [1960], Ernle Bradford's screenplay seems less concerned with Dr. Knox's character than with presenting a series of anaemic fetishistic interludes in the local brothel. Burke and Hare themselves are reduced from the memorable psychotic fiends of Gilling's film to a pair of garrulous Irish comedians, while the Scottish accents affected by most of the minor players are somewhat on the level of Home Counties amateur dramatics. Admittedly, there is some compensation in the glimpses of Dr. Knox's milieu, which allows Sewell to exercise some of his old flair for eccentricity and atmosphere. And Harry Andrews gives one of his best performances to date as Knox, a sinister but dedicated old man whose pompous delight in the more gruesome details of medicine contains something of what the film might have been.
Allmovie wrote, "the producers opted for sexploitation over gruesome horror, but the end result is decidedly dull." The
Radio Times said, "the accent is on sleazy sexploitation and bawdy comedy rather than anything truly macabre or frightening. Arguably the worst film adaptation of the exploits of the notorious
West Port serial killers." ==See also==