The area was long occupied by a variety of indigenous peoples. Burke's Garden was first surveyed in 1748 by a team of
surveyors working for local landowner
James Patton. One of the party, James Burke an Irishman, is said to have thrown away some
potato peelings while cooking. A year later, when the party returned to the area, they found potatoes growing in the area where the peels had been left. The area was dubbed Burke's Garden as something of a joke, but the name stuck. In 1749,
William Ingles went to Burke's Garden to build a house with his uncle, John Ingles. The community was an outpost of German immigrants who settled in the backcountry frontier in the late 18th century. The area remained relatively isolated as it was not near the transportation corridors of major rivers. In the late 19th century, agents for the
Vanderbilt family contacted local farmers about selling land so that the family could build a large estate there. Nobody wanted to sell, and the Vanderbilts instead constructed their
Biltmore Estate near
Asheville, North Carolina. In the 1990s, a small number of
Amish families moved to Burke's Garden, but later they moved out after being unable to purchase enough land and attract enough other Amish families to form a viable community. Today Amish have returned to Burkes Garden and have a thriving community. Lines of scooters can be seen daily outside the Burkes Garden School and Community Center where the Amish now have their own school. According to Chris Wesner of AmishAmerica there Amish community consisted of about 100 persons in 2021. The
county's oldest church, the Central
Lutheran church, is located in Burke's Garden. It originally served multiple denominations so was called Union Church. When the congregation learned their Union Church had joined the Lutheran denomination most members left and established Methodist and Presbyterian churches. In 1952, the community was terrorized by the "
Varmint of Burke's Garden", a large
coyote that killed many local
sheep and caused much damage before being killed. The area is drained by Wolf Creek (a tributary of the
New River) which flows out of the geographic bowl in a northeasterly direction. The entire valley is listed on the
National Register of Historic Places as the '''Burke's Garden Rural Historic District'''; the
Burke's Garden Central Church and Cemetery is also listed on the NRHP. ==See also==