Almost immediately after turning in his badge, Alvord left his wife and turned to crime. He formed a gang with outlaws
Billy Stiles,
Bill Downing, and
"Three Fingered Jack" Dunlop, men he had once pursued during his career as a law officer. Alvord's gang committed several
armed robberies in Cochise County, where he and Stiles were both captured. Somehow, they managed to escape. On February 15, 1900, Dunlop was killed by lawman
Jeff Milton during
a bungled train robbery in Fairbank, Arizona, and gang recruit Bravo Juan Yoas was wounded. Later that year, Alvord was again captured and taken to Tombstone. Billy Stiles rode to Tombstone and wounded the deputy on duty, allowing Alvord and 24 other prisoners to escape. In 1902, Alvord assisted
Arizona Rangers Captain
Burton C. Mossman in capturing the notorious Mexican bandit
Augustine Chacon, in exchange for a share of the reward money and a reduced sentence. When Chacon was convicted of murder and hanged at
Solomonville, Alvord decided it was wiser not to surrender after all. Alvord and Stiles instead returned to crime, now pursued by the Arizona Rangers. They were captured in December 1903, but again managed to escape. Alvord even made a crude attempt at faking their deaths, using the bodies of two unknown
Mexicans. Alvord sent the bodies to Tombstone, claiming they were himself and Stiles. However, an examination quickly showed the dead men were not the two "gringos." The irritated Arizona Rangers finally pursued the outlaws across the border into Mexico, trapping them near
Naco in February 1904. The outlaws resisted, but surrendered after having both been wounded. Alvord spent two years in the
Yuma Territorial Prison. Following his release in 1906, he announced his departure by ship to start anew in
Central America. He was last seen in 1910 working as a
Panama Canal employee. Around that time, he also reportedly worked in railway construction in
Brazil. On July 24, 1910, the
Bisbee Daily Review newspaper (currently the
Sierra Vista Herald) reported, based on information received from an alleged friend of Alvord, that he had recently died of a fever in
Barbados. ==In media==