The Incredible Burt Wonderstone premiered as the opening film of the
SXSW festival on March 8, 2013; it was introduced by Carell, Carrey, and Wilde. The film received a wide release in North America and the United Kingdom on March 15, 2013.
Box office The film earned $22.5 million in North America and $4.9 million elsewhere for a worldwide total of $27.4 million, against a budget of $30 million. In the week prior to its release in North America, the film was predicted to earn approximately $18 million and finish as the number 2 film of the weekend behind
Oz the Great and Powerful. It earned $3.72 million through opening day including midnight showings at 1,800 theaters. Opening weekend earned $10.2 million from 3,160 theaters—an average of $3,221 per theater—ranking third for the weekend behind new release
The Call ($17.1 million) and holdover
Oz the Great and Powerful ($41.3 million). The gross was one of the lowest openings for a Carell or Carrey film. In its second weekend, earnings dropped by 58% to $4.32 million, putting it in seventh place.
Critical reception On review aggregation website
Rotten Tomatoes the film has an approval rating of 37% based on 193 reviews, and an
average rating of 5.16/10. The site's critical consensus reads: "
The Incredible Burt Wonderstone serves up some goofy laughs, but given its outrageous conceit, it's surprisingly safe and predictable." On
Metacritic it has a weighted average score of 44/100 based on reviews from 35 critics, indicating "mixed or average reviews".
CinemaScore polls reported that the average grade moviegoers gave the film was a C+ on a scale of A+ to F. The plot was a focal point for criticism. Reviewers considered the tone uneven, segueing between dark comedy and family film, the extreme stunts of Carrey's Steve Gray, and sentimentality, and serious drama and farcical comedy. Several reviewers noted that the plot was predictable, and dated.
Total Films Matthew Leyland said that the attention to detail in terms of magician gestures, posture and dialog created a "withering showbiz satire", which is sidelined in favor of sentimentality.
Entertainment Weeklys Owen Gleiberman said that the film is too cautious and unimaginative, choosing "earnest and mushy" over increasingly wild surprise, and
Empires Helen O'Hara considered the script unfocused and the tone uneven, which undermined Carell's efforts to portray Wonderstone's return to glory, and
The New York Times Stephen Holden said that the film's message was unoriginal and delivered without any special conviction. In contrast,
Richard Roeper said that it is "dark and wickedly funny", and
Varietys Joe Leydon said that it neatly balanced sentimentality with edgy comedy.
Times Mary Pols said that though the film does not always work, it did so enough that she thought it could be "the kind of semi-bad, semi-inspired comedy that could not only stand repeated viewings but perhaps improve with them". Carrey's performance was generally praised for his humor and return to the physical style of comedy employed early in his career. Roeper said that Carrey is "physical, he's intense, he's ridiculous—and he made me laugh more than any comedic character in recent memory", and Alan Scherstuhl said that Carrey's "cartoon expressiveness" was used to its most judicious ends in years. Gleiberman said Carrey was one of the funniest components of the film, and Holden said that Carrey steals every scene he is in with a "take-no-prisoners ferocity that he hasn't demonstrated in years".
The Boston Globes Ty Burr however said that Carrey is good at being loud, but not funny. Arkin was also praised, with
Chicago Tribunes Michael Phillips saying that he "can't save the movie, but he can save his scenes". Roeper labeled him a marvel, and Leydon called his performance scene-stealing. Leyland said that Carell's likability helped carry the sentimental segments, but Holden considered that his performance gave Wonderstone a soulfulness that undermined the film's farcical aspirations and left the character lacking "a shark's bite". Leydon said that Buscemi offered an engaging performance as the amiable Anton Marvelton, and Wilde was generally considered to have delivered a fine performance in an underwritten role. Pols said that the prospect of Wonderstone attracting Wilde's wholesome and intelligent Jane were absurd, but that Wilde's portrayal was game enough to remove the creepiness. Phillips and
Los Angeles Timess Kenneth Turan criticized Scardino's direction, saying that the film offers slow and crude scenes over the fleet-footed material directed by Scardino on
30 Rock. Leydon conversely said that the director unobtrusively handled the gradual shifts in tone between black comedy and buddy comedy.
Accolades The Incredible Burt Wonderstone received three nominations for the
2013 Teen Choice Awards:
Choice Movie – Comedy,
Choice Movie Actor – Comedy for
Steve Carell, and
Choice Movie Actress – Comedy for
Olivia Wilde. ==See also==