Goldie's work is associated with the contemporary belief that the
Māori were a "dying race". Many Māori value his images of their ancestors highly. On the rare occasions they are offered for sale they fetch high prices, among the highest for New Zealand paintings. Goldie is considered among the most important New Zealand artists, and the prices fetched reflect this view. The 1941 oil portrait of Wharekauri Tahuna was the first painting in New Zealand history to break the $1 million mark, reaching a top price of $1.175 million. In March 2008, NZ$400,000 (NZ$454,000 including buyer's premium) was paid at an International Art Centre auction in Auckland for the painting Hori Pokai - "Sleep, 'tis a gentle thing". Earlier, NZ$530,000 ($589,625 including buyer's premium) was achieved for a Goldie work in an online auction conducted by Fisher Galleries. On 19 November 2010 opera diva Dame
Kiri Te Kanawa sold the oil on canvas "Forty Winks", a portrait of Rutene Te Uamairangi, for NZ$573,000. This was the most paid for a painting at auction in New Zealand at the time, but was later surpassed by Goldie's portrait of Ngāti Manawa chief Wharekauri Tahuna, entitled "A Noble Relic of a Noble Race" (sold in 2016 for NZ$1,300,000 Many Goldies are held in public collections, including those at the
Auckland Art Gallery, the
Auckland Institute and Museum, the
Christchurch Art Gallery, and the
Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa. Some descendants of
Māori represented in Goldie's paintings object to them being sold as prints. In 2022, a group of descendants of chief Kamariera Te Hau Takiri Wharepapa unsuccessfully attempted to raise the funds necessary to buy the painting at auction. In March 2024, six paintings by Goldie were sold at auction in Auckland from the collection of
Mainfreight co-founder Neil Graham. The collection sold for a total of , and included a portrait of Waikato warrior Te Aho-o-te-Rangi Wharepu which sold for .
Forgeries by Karl Sim The convicted art forger
Karl Sim changed his name legally to Carl Fedor Goldie in the 1980s in order to be able to "legitimately" sign his Goldie copies "C. F. Goldie". He published an autobiography with Tim Wilson in 2003 called
Good as Goldie: the amazing story of New Zealand’s most famous art forger. ==Notes==