The Silent Partner did well in Canada both critically and financially, winning several
Canadian Film Academy Awards including Best Picture and Best Director. The film was a
sleeper upon its US release, with Brendon Hanley of the film database
Allmovie noting that the film"...stands out as one of the best sleepers of the late '70s".
Critical Roger Ebert, in his March 30, 1979 review in the
Chicago Sun-Times, awarded three-and-a-half of a possible four stars to the film, calling it "a thriller that is not only intelligently and well acted and very scary, but also has the most audaciously clockwork plot I've seen in a long time." Ebert described it as "worthy of Hitchcock."
Gene Siskel of the
Chicago Tribune gave the film an identical three-and-a-half star grade and called it "a very entertaining caper film." He thought that the film was "predictable" but the characters "are so joyfully written and played that you don't particularly care if you can figure out what's about to happen."
Janet Maslin of
The New York Times wrote, "Just as he did with
Payday, Mr. Duke has put together a dense, quirky, uncommonly interesting movie, this time with a high quotient of suspense. He develops his characters firmly and fast, and populates the story with a lot of them, weighed down by the monotony of their lives but still, senselessly, always on the go."
Variety called it "one of the films that run the gamut from intrigue to violence. The excellent cast is headed by Susannah York, Christopher Plummer and Elliott Gould. It is entertaining."
Kevin Thomas of the
Los Angeles Times wrote that the film was "tense and ingenious under Duke's light touch and boasts a fine Oscar Peterson score." Gary Arnold of
The Washington Post stated, "Before it takes an appalling turn for the vicious,
The Silent Partner seems an uncommonly clever and gripping suspense thriller. Even after the story threatens to self-destruct, you fight the impulse to suffer a major letdown, for the sake of the swell nerve-racking time you've been having up to that point."
Jay Scott wrote in
The Globe and Mail, "As a suspense picture,
The Silent Partner is first class: the story is told cleanly and the coincidences don't strain credulity unduly, although I wish screenwriter Hanson had not exhausted his imagination on the plot — the dialogue clunks when it should canter." Even though it was the only film in competition that had not been seen by the public, it won six awards: best picture (for producers Garth Drabinsky, Joel Michaels, Stephen Young); best director (Daryl Duke); sound recording (David Lee); sound editing (Bruce Nyznik); original music (Oscar Peterson); and editing (George Appleby). ==Legacy==