Upon its release,
Larry Flick of
Billboard considered the song to be "an equally literate, highly potent pop/rock journey" to Hawkins' debut single "
Damn I Wish I Was Your Lover". He praised the single remix for providing "more emphasis on the melody" and giving it "a lighter, more accessible tone". Randy Clark of
Cash Box commented, "With her
Madonna-meets-
Chrissie Hynde voice and unusually structured songwriting style, Sophie could get more
AC play on this track."
Music & Media stated, "With this follow up to 'Damn I Wish I Was Your Lover', this young singer/songwriter is destined to become the next
Cyndi Lauper." Victoria Thieberger of
The Age noted Hawkins' "distinctive voice" was "measured but warm" on the track. She also praised the song for being "richly orchestrated with a romantic synth sound over a heavy bass". ==Track listings==