Multiple critics praised "Can You Feel My Heart" as a good illustration of the album, in particular the presence of
electronic elements driven by the addition of keyboardist Jordan Fish to the band. Dean Brown of
PopMatters explained that "Where the swathes of artificial electronica on [previous album]
There Is a Hell... sounded disengaged from the music, Jordan Fish's contributions here are seamlessly incorporated and audible from the bright beginnings of opener "Can You Feel My Heart"".
BBC Music's Mike Diver noted that the track, alongside earlier single "
Sleepwalking", "present[s] new, synthetic textures to the forefront of the BMTH mix". Other reviews published by
AllMusic,
Alternative Press and
Exclaim! identified the
Sempiternal opener as a highlight of the album.
The Guardian writer Dom Lawson was less positive, criticising the song's "
dubstep swagger and overwrought synths". "Can You Feel My Heart" has also been included in several commentators' lists of the best Bring Me the Horizon songs –
Alternative Press included it at number two on their list in May 2015, Loudwire ranked it at number six in May 2014, and
AXS named it the seventh best in May 2015.
Metal Hammer writer Luke Morton ranked it the fifth best song by the band, highlighting it as "the point the metal game changed" due to its use of electronics, which he claimed was "the finest use of electronics ever in a BMTH song". In 2019,
Billboard ranked the song number eight on their list of the 10 greatest Bring Me the Horizon songs, and in 2022,
Kerrang! ranked the song number six on their list of the 20 greatest Bring Me the Horizon songs. ==Commercial performance==