Top 10 – Canada Rocks! Top 9 – The Rolling Stones Top 8 – The 80s Top 7 – Classic Rock Top 6 – Unplugged Top 5 – Country Top 4 – Judge's Choice Top 3 – Standards Finale Each contestant sang three songs.
The Judges' Comments Listed below is a selection of criticisms and praises from the Judges Jake Gold, Sass Jordan, Farley Flex and Zack Werner from the Top 5 Performance show to the season finale. The songs the idols sang during the performance show can be seen on the list above.
Top 2 Performance Show Eva Avila (Winner) • Sass Jordan: "You are an international artist and you are the jewel in the Canadian Idol crown" (1-Wild Horses) • Jake Gold: "I'd love to hear the recorded version of that song. It was wonderful" (2-Meant to Fly) • Zack Werner: "You're a songwriter's dream." (2-Meant to Fly) • Farley Flex: "Your performance was my favourite performance on Idol, but not just of you, of anybody" (3-How come you don't call me) • Zack Werner: "Clive Davis should come here and kiss your Canadian ***" (3-How come you don't call me) • Sass Jordan, Farley Flex, Jake Gold: [STANDING OVATION](3-How come you don't call me)
Craig Sharpe (Runner Up) • Jake Gold: "That was, without a doubt, the best thing you've done on this show" (1-Meant to Fly) • Farley Flex: "To step up at this point in time shows you're a man to be respected" (1-Meant to Fly) • Zack Werner: (Hugged Craig) (1-Meant to Fly) • Zack Werner: "You're the Freddie Mercury of Canada" (2-I Surrender) • Sass Jordan: "The first time I saw you in Newfoundland I knew you were a star and my opinion hasn't changed a bit" (3-What hurts the most)
Top 3 Performance Show Tyler Lewis: (Eliminated) • Farley Flex: "You just got the most votes for one singular body movement" (1) • Zack Werner: "It wasn't very much on the singing part but I think you may just have won Canada's next top model" (1) • Sass Jordan: "Tyler...it had to be you!" (2) • Farley Flex:: "You really took it by the horns" (2)
Eva Avila • Sass Jordan: "You just did something that people can only do when they're born with it" (1) • Zack Werner: "No disrespect to Kalan, but he's no Eva Avila" (1) • Zack Werner: "Dude, I don't rap, you shouldn't scat," (2)
Craig Sharpe: • Jake Gold: "I just didn't feel like you got into the song." (1) • Zack Werner: "Kickstart this thing, man. Be a star, dude" (1) • Jake Gold: "At the end you brought it right home." (2) • Sass Jordan: "That was an unbelievably lovely performance" (2)
Top 4 Performance Show Craig Sharpe: • Zack Werner: "The fact is that song totally fits your pipes and your vibe and if you won this thing and released it, it would go number one" (1) • Farley Flex: "It was really easy to choose songs for you" (2)
Tyler Lewis: • Zack Werner: "I was all ready to go 'he shoots, he scores,' but you came out really flat in the third period" (1) • Zack Werner: "You scared some children under their beds." (2)
Chad Doucette: (Eliminated) • Jake Gold: "You delivered it. You did exactly what we thought you would do with that song." (1) • Farley Flex: "The most memorable voice on the show" (1) • Sass Jordan: "I've got to say I was hurting a bit at the beginning, but you totally redeemed yourself with that moment at the end" (2)
Eva Avila: • Farley Flex: "You gave us a vision of who you will be." (1) • Jake Gold: "I thought vocally it was really good, but... it's an angry song, but you were smiling" (1) • Zack Werner: "I say Canadian Idol: Eva Avila." (2)
Top 5 Performance Show Eva Avila: • Jake Gold: "I always wondered how you were going to do country and you took that song and made it Eva. You made it work" • Sass Jordan: "You're just getting better and better"
Craig Sharpe: • Farley Flex: "I think the biggest thing in that performance was the maturity you showed," • Zack Werner: "I felt it, but you have such a unique instrument, I want you to be as big and obnoxious as me. Or Jake."
Steffi D.: (Eliminated) • Zack Werner: "It's very cornball... But I think people have to decide, as much as I love you, if you're the next Canadian Idol."
Tyler Lewis: • Farley Flex: "I'm no Farley Pride but your kinfolk should be proud."
Chad Doucette: • Zack Werner: "But to be honest, I didn't even remember I was here. I was just watching that, remembering how much I care for you from the beginning."
Song Themes Each week, a song theme will be presented to the competitors. Each competitor must base their song choice on the theme of the week. • July 17 -
Canada Rocks! - Songs written & recorded by Canadian Artists. • July 24 -
The Rolling Stones • July 31 - Music of The 1980s • August 7 -
Classic rock • August 14 -
Unplugged (
Acoustic music) • August 21 -
Country music • August 28 - ''Judges' Choice'' • September 4 -
Pop standards Performers on results shows Each week, a guest performer will appear on the results show to perform one song. The guests will be listed here. • July 18 -
Nelly Furtado singing "
Promiscuous" • July 25 -
(No Performer) • August 1 -
Cyndi Lauper singing "
Time After Time" and "
Shine" • August 8 -
Dennis DeYoung &
Roger Hodgson • August 15 -
Chantal Kreviazuk singing "In This Life" (accompanied by the Top 6) and "
All I Can Do" • August 22 -
Martina McBride singing "
I Can't Stop Loving You" (accompanied by the Top 5) and "Till I Can Make It On My Own" • August 29 -
Rex Goudie singing "Run" • September 5 -
Tony Bennett • Finale-
Melissa O'Neil,
Nelly Furtado singing "Maneater", Canadian Idol Top 10 ==Releases==