The historian
Mike Dash notes that many authors who publicized the "Philadelphia Experiment" story after that of Jessup appeared to have conducted little or no research of their own. Through the late 1970s, for example, Allende/Allen was often described as mysterious and difficult to locate, but Goerman determined Allende/Allen's identity after only a few telephone calls. Observers have argued that it is inappropriate to grant credence to an unusual story promoted by one individual in the absence of corroborating evidence. Robert Goerman wrote in
Fate magazine in 1980, that "Carlos Allende"/"Carl Allen", who is said to have corresponded with Jessup, was Carl Meredith Allen of
New Kensington, Pennsylvania, who had an established history of
psychiatric illness and who may have fabricated the primary history of the experiment as a result of his mental illness. Goerman later realized that Allen was a family friend and "a creative and imaginative loner… sending bizarre writings and claims".
Timeline inconsistencies USS
Eldridge was not commissioned until August 27, 1943, and it remained in port in
New York City until September 1943. The October experiment allegedly took place while the ship was on its first
shakedown cruise in
the Bahamas, which
conspiracy theorists try to explain away by claiming that the
ship's logs might have been falsified or else still be
classified. Conspiracy theorists also attempt to explain away the inconsistency by claiming that was actually used rather than USS
Eldridge as USS
Hammann arrived in the shipyard on October 20, 1943, ignoring the "eyewitness statements" from Carl M. Allen which launched the hoax in the first place. The
Office of Naval Research (ONR) stated in September 1996, "ONR has never conducted investigations on radar invisibility, either in 1943 or at any other time." Pointing out that the ONR was not established until 1946, it denounces the accounts of "The Philadelphia Experiment" as complete "
science fiction". A reunion of Navy veterans who had served aboard USS
Eldridge told a Philadelphia newspaper in April 1999 that their ship had never made port in Philadelphia. Further evidence discounting the Philadelphia Experiment timeline comes from USS
Eldridge’s complete World War II action report, including the remarks section of the 1943 deck log, available on
microfilm. describes a procedure on board , which was docked alongside the
Eldridge in 1943. The operation involved the generation of a powerful electromagnetic field on board the ship in order to
deperm or
degauss it, with the goal of rendering the ship undetectable or "invisible" to magnetically fused undersea
mines and
torpedoes. This system was invented by a Canadian,
Charles F. Goodeve, when he held the rank of
commander in the
Royal Canadian Naval Volunteer Reserve, and the
Royal Navy and other navies used it widely during World War II. British ships of the era often included such degaussing systems built into the upper decks (the
conduits are still visible on the deck of in London, for example). Degaussing is still used today. However, it has no effect on visible light or radar. Vallée speculates that accounts of USS ''Engstrom's'' degaussing might have been garbled and
confabulated in subsequent retellings, and that these accounts may have influenced the story of "The Philadelphia Experiment". Vallée cites a veteran who served on board USS
Engstrom and who suggests it might have traveled from Philadelphia to Norfolk and back again in a single day at a time when merchant ships could not, by use of the
Chesapeake & Delaware Canal and
Chesapeake Bay, which at the time was open only to naval vessels. Use of that channel was kept quiet: German submarines had ravaged shipping along the East Coast during
Operation Drumbeat, and thus military ships unable to protect themselves were secretly moved via canals to avoid the threat. The same veteran claims to be the man that Allende witnessed "disappearing" at a bar. He claims that when a fight broke out, friendly barmaids whisked him out of the bar before the police arrived, because he was under age for drinking. They then covered for him by claiming that he had disappeared. ==See also==