After gaining her freedom in 1863, Caroline moved to
Franklin County, Arkansas, where several townships were established for newly
freed Black people. When she settled in Newport, Arkansas, she began to gain notoriety as a seer. While she did not charge for her services, patrons always left her a monetary offering. With the pension from her husband's death and the donations, she purchased land and constructed rental property, not far from the business district of Newport. While Aunt Caroline rejected the title of
fortune teller, many of her clients identified her as a prophet, who had the ability to see the future. She did not use
tarot cards nor
crystal balls, and she was not known to
palm read. She used a regular deck of playing cards that she would spread out in front of her to help with her concentration. Other times, she simply looked at the person and could tell them what they needed to know. Believers in her abilities were
Black,
white and
Indigenous. Her house was constantly full, especially on the weekends. As visitors exited the Rock Island trains in droves to make their way to her home, she was known to cook up
soul food plates and sell them. It was not long before news of her abilities spread throughout the
Mid-South. People traveled from as far as 400 miles away to seek Aunt Caroline's wisdom, according to historian
John Quincy Wolf. She helped people find long-lost relatives, lost pets, jewelry and other personal items. After one man paid her a visit to help find his lost hogs, she reportedly told him "Your hogs were stolen. Go down the road to the fifth house from you, go back to the barn and you'll find yo' hogs in a stable. Unlatch the door and leave it open and yo' hogs will come home. Don't go today because the people who live there are home. But tomorrow they'll be gone for the day. So you go tomorrow." While prominent residents of Newport mocked her abilities in public, they sought her instruction before they made any important decisions, especially those pertaining to business. They begged her to keep their late-night visits to her home a secret. She would often confront those who were skeptical of her gifts and prove them wrong. It was reported by one of her servants that a man came to her with help finding his mules, but he did not really think she could find them. Aunt Caroline told him, "You don' think I can tell you where your mules is but I can. Go down the Tuckerman road four miles till you come to a big holler and they's a lot of timber in the holler. Go up the holler till you hear yo' mules brayin.' They'll be locked up in a barn, but on the near side of the barn, they's a foundation block and on the block you'll find the key." ==Hoodoo woman==