In 1992
Computer Gaming World reviewed the new version of
Carriers at War, which it described as having "only a superficial resemblance to its 8-bit predecessor" with a mouse-driven interface. The magazine praised the realism of combat including the
fog of war, and liked the intelligence of the computer opponent while stating that a human was still better. It concluded that "
CAW is the most accurate simulation of carrier warfare available and is by far the best for solitaire play. Players interested in the Pacific Theater of World War II should not miss it". A 1993 survey by
Computer Gaming World of wargames rated the revised version three-plus stars, criticizing the lack of a campaign. In 1994 the magazine said that the MS-DOS version "was a milestone in computer wargame history". The game was reviewed in 1993 in
Dragon #193 by Hartley, Patricia, and Kirk Lesser in "The Role of Computers" column. The reviewers gave the game 4 out of 5 stars. In 1996,
Computer Gaming World declared
Carriers at War the 90th-best computer game ever released. The magazine's wargame columnist Terry Coleman named it his pick for the sixth-best computer wargame released by late 1996. ==See also==