Catch 22 was fronted by guitarist/vocalist
Tomas Kalnoky and drummer Chris Greer who recruited trumpeter Kevin Gunther, who was working in a local record store.
Bassist Jason Scharenguivel, saxophonist
Ryan Eldred, and
trombonist Todd Seaman rounded out the original lineup. Greer, Kalnoky, and Scharenguivel were formerly in "Gimp" before Tomas fronted Catch 22. The band released a self-produced demo tape,
Rules of the Game, in 1997. All 2000 copies of the tape quickly sold out. The band mailed several copies to labels they were interested in working with including
Gainesville,
Florida's Toybox Records (who had previously released a 7" by
Less Than Jake). Toybox was owned and operated by Sean Bonner, who had recently moved to
Chicago,
Illinois to work at
Victory Records. Sean brought the tape to the Victory office and suggested the band be signed. Scharenguivel and Seaman left the band and was replaced by
Josh Ansley and Jamie Egan respectively. The band then signed to Victory Records and produced their first studio album, 1998's
Keasbey Nights. Ansley left and was replaced by
Pat Calpin.
Kalnoky left the band shortly thereafter, deciding (due in part to parental pressure) to continue his education rather than tour. Catch 22 continued on with Pat Calpin moving to guitar, Pat Kays (nicknamed "Mingus") on bass, and Jeff Davidson on vocals. After recording the
Washed Up! EP, Egan left the band to continue his teaching career and focus on family life.
Alone in a Crowd followed in 2000 with Mike Soprano on trombone. After this release, the band began touring heavily on a national scale, appearing with
Mustard Plug,
Reel Big Fish, and other third-wave ska, hardcore, and punk acts. Davidson and Soprano left the band in 2001 to pursue other projects, and for a while the band actively courted new vocalists, even putting an advertisement on their website. The group also recruited Ian McKenzie, formerly of
Long Island,
New York ska band
Edna's Goldfish on trombone/vocals. On February 23, 2002, the band performed at
Birch Hill Nightclub in
Old Bridge, New Jersey with Gunther as the lead vocalist since Eldred was unavailable that night. Various members from Last Picked, a fellow ska band from Rahway, NJ, volunteered to fill in the horn section. After a fruitless search, the band decided to continue on as it was, with
Ryan Eldred and Kevin Gunther sharing vocal duties.
Washed Up and Through the Ringer, an expansion of the
Washed Up! EP, was released in 2001, featuring two new songs, three rarities from the
Alone in a Crowd era, and a handful of live tracks recorded in October 2000 at Club Laga in
Pittsburgh and Euclid Tavern in
Ohio. The band released its third full-length album,
Dinosaur Sounds, in 2003, roughly the same time
Streetlight Manifesto (a band founded by Tomas Kalnoky and featuring Josh Ansley, Jamie Egan, Jim Conti, and later Mike Soprano as well as former members of the NJ ska band
One Cool Guy) released their debut album
Everything Goes Numb. Both albums featured supposed veiled attacks on each other, suggesting to many fans that there was some sort of disagreement or heat between Catch 22 and Streetlight Manifesto. While there was a disagreement, the two parties have since reconciled their differences. Catch 22's Kevin Gunther has since been in charge of Streetlight Manifesto's tour booking for many years, and members of both bands have said in conversations with fans that there is no "beef" between the two. In 2004, Catch 22 released
Live, a combination CD and DVD recording of a show performed at
The Downtown in
Farmingdale, New York, earlier that year. In 2006, they released their fourth studio album,
Permanent Revolution, a concept album centering on the life of Russian Marxist revolutionary
Leon Trotsky. Its title was coined after Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution. In April 2009, the band embarked on a European tour, which included a performance at the
Groezrock festival. They played a few Northeastern US shows in August 2009. In July 2010, former vocalist Jeff Davidson returned as a guest performer to sing a few songs at one show, making it his first performance with the band since 2001. After a few East Coast shows, the band went on a European tour through to August 2010. Davidson joined the band again to perform
Alone in a Crowd in full at Starland Ballroom in Sayreville, NJ on January 30, 2016. In February 2012, Catch 22's official website showed that they would be making an appearance at Bamboozle 2012. After a hiatus, in February 2015, Catch 22 was listed as a performer for Amnesia Rockfest in Montebello, Quebec. Jamie Egan returned to Catch 22 in 2019, replacing Dave Solomon. Mike Corvasce also replaced Pat Kays. In November 2022, the band played their 100th show as a band, as part of
Skanksgiving at
Starland Ballroom. In October 2023, the band confirmed in a Facebook comment that they have been working on material, and would hopefully get something out by 2024. However, that year saw no new releases. Near the end of April 2024, Jamie's son Connor started performing in the band as a touring member. On October 5, 2024, Catch 22 played at the Monster Energy Stage at
Furnace Fest in Birmingham, Alabama. On February 21, 2025, it was announced the band will reunite with former lead vocalist Jeff Davidson once again for the 25th anniversary of their album
Alone in a Crowd at the Supernova Ska Festival in
Fort Monroe, Hampton, Virginia on September 12 to 14, 2025. At Reggies Chicago, Chicago, IL, Catch 22 performed a new song titled "Lover's Scorn." The song was played acoustically by saxophonist Ryan Eldred a decade prior. ==Music==