Minor leagues Ball started playing organized baseball on the semi-pro team in
Three Rivers, Michigan, where he played in a game against
Hall of Fame Negro league star
Rube Foster of the
Otsego Independents during the 1902 season. He then proceeded to play for
Montgomery Senators, a
minor league team that competed in the
Southern League. He played for the team until , when he signed for the
New York Highlanders.
New York Highlanders (1907–09) During his rookie season, Ball posted a
batting average of .247 and led the majors in
strikeouts with 91. Defensively, he committed the most
errors among all fielders in the
American League with 81 and most errors by a shortstop with 80, However, he also set the team record for most assists by a rookie with 438
Cleveland Naps (1909–12) On May 18, , the Cleveland Naps bought Ball’s contract for approximately $5,000 (worth $ in ). Ball was brought in to serve as the temporary replacement for Cleveland's injured starting shortstop
Terry Turner, who suffered from a recurring arm injury. he achieved baseball history when he executed the first
unassisted triple play in the MLB on July 19, 1909, doing so against the
Boston Red Sox at
League Park. In the second inning of the game, Ball, playing
shortstop, caught
Amby McConnell's line drive, stepped on second base to retire
Heinie Wagner, and then tagged
Jake Stahl as he was advancing towards second. Because the play was unprecedented and turned so swiftly, the ballplayers on the field did not know the inning was over, and the crowd of 11,000 were unsure of how to react.
Cy Young, the game's
starting pitcher, was puzzled and asked Ball why he was leaving the field. In the following inning, with the crowd still cheering, he hit an
inside-the-park home run to center field, which was his only home run that season. At the end of the season, after playing just 54 games with the team, He refused to play for the minor league team and this, coupled with the underperformance of the infielders brought in to replace him, resulted in the Naps repurchasing his contract. The season turned out to be Ball's best statistical year, with several career highs. He batted .296 with 122 hits, 9
triples, 45 RBI and 3 home runs, though he also recorded the third highest number of strikeouts in the AL with 93. Although his defense was never stellar, and held the Yankees (his former team) to a 3–3 draw when he, serving as the
cut-off man, successfully relayed the ball thrown from
right fielder Shoeless Joe Jackson to
catcher Gus Fisher. In doing so, he nailed
Birdie Cree (who represented the Yankees' winning run) at
home plate and the game was immediately suspended due to darkness. However, in a rematch against the White Sox on May 5, 1912, Ball suffered a momentary defensive lapse that ultimately cost his team the game. In the sixth inning, he was unable to
catch Shano Collins stealing second base and then inexplicably held onto the ball. This allowed
Ping Bodie to advance to home plate and score the winning run.
Boston Red Sox (1912–13) On June 25, 1912, the
Boston Red Sox purchased Ball's contract from the Naps for $2,500 (equivalent to $ in ). The Red Sox signed Ball with the intention of using him only as a
utility player who could substitute for any injured players on the team. As a result, he rarely started for the Red Sox. The team advanced to the
World Series at the end of that season, Although he struck out in his only
plate appearance of the series, This prompted the
Ottawa Citizen to label him "the luckiest man in baseball." ==Post-playing career==