Critcher was the daughter of Judge
John Critcher and Elizabeth "Lizzie" Thomasia Kennon (Whiting) Critcher; she was their fourth daughter and the youngest of their five children. She grew up on the family plantation, Audley, in
Oak Grove, Virginia, and showed an early interest in equestrianism and painting. Critcher's first studies came at the Arlington Institute in Virginia. She then studied at
Cooper Union in New York City for a year, with
Eliphalet Frazer Andrews at the
Corcoran School of Art in Washington, D.C., and also with
Richard Emil Miller She soon began receiving commissions, producing a number of portraits of members of prominent Virginia families. In 1897 she was occupying studio space in the former Minor house in Alexandria, located on North Alfred Street. She traveled to Paris in 1904, remaining in that city for several years. In 1919 she founded another school, this time in Washington, called variously The School of Painting and Applied Arts She ran the school until 1940, when she decided to devote herself to painting full-time. During the 1910s and 1920s she lived at The Woodley in Washington. this is also given as the first address of her school, which later moved to a location along
Connecticut Avenue. Among the institution's pupils was
Sarah Blakeslee, whom Critcher encouraged to enroll in the
Chester Springs branch of the
Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts upon graduation from high school. Critcher was assisted in running the school by her sister Louisa Kennon Critcher, known as "Lulie", who was also an artist. The honor brought her great pleasure; she wrote to her friend,
C. Powell Minnigerode, "You will be pleased, I know, to hear that a letter just rec’d from
Mr. Couse informs me that I have been unanimously elected to active membership in the Taos Society of Artists. It is nice to be the first and only woman in it. I am feeling very good about it." Unlike many members of the Taos Society, Critcher never lived in New Mexico permanently, choosing to summer there instead for several years; it was said of her that she would return to Washington "with a wrinkled, deeply suntanned skin in the 1920s when that was not fashionable". In the 1940s and 1950s she lived in
Charles Town, West Virginia, completing at least forty-two portraits during her residence there. ==Work==