Cauterize was released to critical acclaim.
Allmusic's James Christopher Monger did not award a star rating to the album (as with
All I Was), but he was nonetheless positive in his appraisal, stating "The ten-track set is bolstered by a pair of strong singles in "Another Heart" and "Flying Monkeys," as well as some deft work from new bass player Wolfgang Van Halen."
Revolver gave it 3.5 out of 5, saying of the album, "Like 2012's
All I Was,
Cauterize is another successful fusion of
thrash metal, soaring solos and Tremonti 's powerful
post-grunge vocals".
About.com stated, "Tremonti is in control as a frontman, slinging out devilish riffs and passionate vocals.
Cauterize is not just for fans of the guitarist or his other projects, but those that love music that is both aggressive and infectious" and gave the album 4 out of 5 stars.
Ultimate Guitar gave the album 8.3/10 and said they felt like the album had a lot more sonic variety than expected, and they found themselves impressed with things they weren't even expecting from Mark Tremonti, including "the deep and introspective nature of the lyrics, some of the softer and slower passages, and the awesome vocal performance." However, they thought Wolfgang Van Halen's playing was a weak point on the album.
CrypticRock gave
Cauterize a perfect 5 out of 5 score, saying "Tremonti colors his music with a message of hope and wraps it inside those hard-hitting, skin-pounding beats that take the listener from tumultuous storms to calm seas, but these contradictions in mood are intentional, crafted in a calculated and meticulous manner" and that "Tremonti strives for perfection, to make the next creative endeavor better than the previous, and each one proves to be just that."
Cauterize sold approximately 13,000 copies in its first week, debuting at #40 on the US
Billboard Top 200 albums chart. ==Track listing==