Fandom Cecil is a popular character within the
Night Vale fandom; and Cranor has attributed much of the show's popularity to the pairing. More generally, he was described by
Wired as being "at the heart of [Night Vale’s] enduring appeal" to fans, and the
Journal of Radio & Audio Media said that Cecil's delivery of the script, or more specifically, the parts where he broke away from the script, "endear[ed]" him to the audience and, like real talk radio, allowed for the audience to grow closer to him. Few aspects of Cecil's physical appearance are revealed to the audience and, Artists often depict Cecil with similar attributes; he is white, wears glasses, who wears sweater vests, suspenders, and some form of tie. Cecil is also frequently depicted as an abled-bodied white man; this has caused contention within the fandom. The common fan imagining of Cecil has led to Cecil's doppelganger, Kevin, who is voiced by African American actor Kevin R. Free, being drawn as white as well. In
The Iconography of Fanart, EJ Nielsen argued that drawing Kevin as white could be seen as
whitewashing within the fandom. Drawings depicting Cecil as non-white do exist and are looked on favorably by Baldwin.
Critical reception and analysis In
Critical Approaches to Welcome to Night Vale, in reference to Cecil's openness and his relationship with Carlos, and the town's nonplussed reaction, Stobbart described it as "refreshing and heartening for a work of fiction to display a society where homophobia seemingly does not exist". A
Berkeley Technology Law Journal article argued that Cecil, through his online popularity, had likely "attained the characterization and the cultural and economic value" needed to be considered copyrightable in the US as laid out by
DC Comics v. Mark Towle, but said it was "unclear" whether Cecil had enough of a physical presence needed to qualify for protection. In the 2014 and 2015 Audio Verse Awards, Baldwin won "Best Actor in an Original Leading Role" and "Best Actor with a Leading Role in an Original, Long-Form, Serial Production" for his role as Cecil. ==References==