Celestial was named the 53rd-finest metal record of the decade by
Decibel, stating that "it's seen as a transitional record between the band's early work and the post-metal benchmarks such as
Oceanic, but
Celestial holds up in ways different from their later work [...] the elements of the greatness are present, but rawer, more direct."
Rock Sound placed it at #3 in their rundown of their top albums of 2001 and
Metal Hammer named it one of the 20 best metal albums of 2000. In 2011, William York, writing for
AllMusic, described the album as Isis' best, and argues that the record needs to be “given time” – that it eventually develops an “almost epic feel”. ==Track listing==