The Center and Gaffney have been criticized for propagating conspiracy theories by
Dana Milbank of
The Washington Post, Simon Maloy of
Salon, CNN national security analyst
Peter Bergen,
Grover Norquist,
Jonathan Kay,
Georgetown University's
Prince Alwaleed Center for Muslim–Christian Understanding,
Center for American Progress,
Media Matters for America, the
Southern Poverty Law Center,
The Intercept, the
Anti-Defamation League, and the
Institute for Southern Studies, among others. Gaffney has been described as an influential member of the
counter-jihad movement, and the CPS has been described as "arguably the most important" counter-jihad advocacy group. In 2016, the
Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) labeled the CSP as a
hate group and a "conspiracy-oriented mouthpiece for the growing anti-Muslim movement", a characterization disputed by the CSP. SPLC representatives have characterized the CSP as "an extremist think tank" and suggested that it is led by an "anti-muslim conspiracy theorist." The SPLC further criticizes CSP's "investigative reports", saying that they are designed "to reinforce [Frank] Gaffney's delusions". Writing in
Religion Dispatches,
Sarah Posner described the organization as "a
far-right think tank whose president, Frank Gaffney, was banned from the
CPAC [Conservative Political Action Conference] ... because its organizers believed him to be a 'crazy bigot'". The Center for Democratic Values at
Queens College, City University of New York has said the center is among the "key players in the Sharīʿah cottage industry", which it describes as a "conspiracy theory" that claims the existence of "secretive power elite groups that conspire to replace sovereign nation-states in order to eventually rule the world". In March 1995,
William M. Arkin, a reporter and commentator on military affairs, criticized the CSP's Gaffney as a "maestro of bumper-sticker policy" who "specializes in intensely personal attacks" and who has "never met a flag-waving, pro-defense, anti-Democratic idea he didn't like." Gaffney has also generated controversy for writing in 2010 that the logo of the
U.S. Missile Defense Agency "appears ominously to reflect a morphing of the Islamic crescent and star with the Obama campaign logo" and was part of a "worrying pattern of official U.S. submission to Islam". ==See also==