The
St. Petersburg Times opined, "Although it may be a botched attempt at moving in a more acoustic direction,
Cerulean is a complete disaster, and unravels all the promise that the Ocean Blue originally showed."
Dave Eggers, in
The Daily Illini, said that the lyrics "are delicate, poetic and small-scaled." In 1999, the
Portland Press Herald included the album on its list of the 90 "best CDs of the '90s that no one heard". In 2024, the
Star Tribune noted that the music "fell in with the more mopey, lusher, prettier brand of pre-
Nirvana alternative rock led by groups like
the Cure,
New Order,
the Church and fellow Sire label mates
Echo & the Bunnymen." ==Track listing==