Rob Walker of
Slate found the advertisement "fantastic", comparing it to
Franz Kafka's short story "
Give it Up!"
Jeff Goodby compared the advertisement to
Nike's "
Tag", interpreted the advertisement as a warning to consumers to enjoy life in a
post-9/11 world. Goodby, preferring the Xbox commercial, stated "It's interesting they're both about play. But one is happy. The other is dire."
Awards Despite the controversial nature of the advertisement, the advertisement won several awards, including: • 2002:
Cannes Lions – International Advertising Festival, Gold Lion for Entertainment & Leisure. • 2003: Art Directors Club of Europe Awards – Overall Grand Prix and Gold Winner for Cinema Commercials. • 2003:
British Television Advertising Awards – Silvers for Virals & Cinema. • 2003:
D&AD – Silver Awards for TV & Cinema Advertising: Cinema Commercials Individual & Campaigns, and for Direction • 2003: International Andy Awards ==References==