Mikael Wood from the
Los Angeles Times gave the album a mixed review, saying that it "darts somewhat haphazardly from sleek dance-pop tunes ... to schmaltzy slow jams" but also that "it also feels like an honest showcase of the singer's voice ... its strength lives up to that of [his] collaborators."
AllMusic's Andy Kellman gave it 3 out of 5 stars and wrote "As a showcase for a teenage powerhouse vocalist,
Charice does succeed, but a more balanced mix of heart-heavy and upbeat material would have made the desired
Whitney Houston and
Mariah Carey comparisons more accurate".
Billboard gave the album a generally positive review, noting that "the set's stylistic shifts—from teen-oriented pop to a touch of rock ("In Love So Deep") to anthemic ballads—ultimately leaves you wondering just which audience [Zyrus] is eyeing: [his] teen peers or their moms," before concluding that "Though it doesn't hit on all cylinders, the album leaves no doubt as to [Zyrus's] talent—and promising future." ==Commercial performance==