Byrne was living in London at the same time as the pre-eminent surgeon and anatomist
John Hunter. Hunter had a reputation for collecting unusual specimens for his private museum, and Hunter had offered to pay Byrne for his corpse. As Byrne's health deteriorated, and knowing that Hunter wanted his body for dissection (a fate reserved at that time for executed criminals) and probable display, Byrne devised a plan. He made express arrangements with friends that when he died his body would be sealed in a lead coffin and taken to the coastal town of
Margate and then to a ship for burial at sea. Byrne's wishes were thwarted and his worst fears realised when Hunter arranged for the cadaver to be snatched on its way to Margate. The coffin was made and measured 9 feet 4 inches in length, but Hunter nevertheless acquired the body. Hunter then reduced Byrne's corpse to its skeleton and four years later put Byrne's skeleton on display in his Hunterian Museum. His skeleton was purchased in 1799 by the
Hunterian Museum at the
Royal College of Surgeons in London and it was then displayed for nearly two centuries. A public poll conducted on the
BMJ website over December 2011—January 2012 in response to the article "Should the Skeleton of 'the Irish Giant' Be Buried at Sea?" by Doyal and Muinzer offered people the chance to vote on what they thought should happen to Byrne's remains. Doyal and Muinzer reported: "On the last count that we saw before voting ceased, 55.6% (310) voted for burial at sea; 13.17% (74) for removal from display and being kept for research; and 31.55% (176) for the status quo." The
BMJ article was widely reported and the resulting swell of public support for the campaign forced The Royal College of Surgeons to formally consider whether it should release Byrne's skeleton, the showpiece of their Hunterian Museum, in February 2012. They decided to continue the exhibit. A further academic article was published in the
International Journal of Culture and Property Law On 6 June 2018, speaking on behalf of the campaign, Muinzer published an article in
The Conversation entitled "Why a London museum should return the stolen bones of an Irish giant" as a result of recent developments with the case. Following renewed pressure from campaigners,
The Guardian reported in a 2018 article entitled "'Irish giant' may finally get respectful burial after 200 years on display" that the Trustees of the Hunterian Museum have confirmed that they will consider whether to release the skeleton of Charles Byrne for burial. A spokesperson for the Royal College of Surgeons said "The Hunterian Museum will be closed [from late 2016] until 2021 and Charles Byrne's skeleton is not currently on display. The board of trustees of the Hunterian collection will be discussing the matter during the period of closure of the museum". Carla Valentine, technical curator of the Pathology Museum at Queen Mary University, London, said: "Now that it's out there that they're considering this, I think it will be difficult to go back from that". The article set out a proposed legal case for Byrne's burial, based on common law principles mainly drawn from corpse disposal law. It suggested that, were a person seeking to arrange Byrne's sea burial to challenge the Hunterian Museum in an English court for lawful possession of his remains, the court would grant them this possession. She argued in her 2022 PhD that English law has always prioritised the dignity of the human corpse, treating it as if it is still to some degree a person owed human dignity, and that it would do so for Byrne if the current situation were challenged - noting that the law can only intervene in such a matter if asked. On 11 January 2023, the Hunterian Museum announced official retirement of Byrne's skeleton from public display. The museum instead will display an oil portrait of John Hunter by painter
Sir Joshua Reynolds, completed in 1789. This portrait features the feet of Byrne's skeleton hanging above Hunter in the upper righthand corner. ==Medical condition==