On 5 January 1789 while at Tahiti and three months before departure, three crew members, Charles Churchill, along with the gunner’s mate John Millward and seaman
William Muspratt deserted ship, taking the ship's cutter, muskets and ammunition. Muspratt had recently been flogged for neglect of duty. Bligh records the incident in the ship's log: Among belongings Churchill left on the
Bounty included a list of names that Bligh construed as more accomplices in a planned desertion. Bligh later asserted that the names included those of midshipman
Peter Heywood and
Fletcher Christian. Churchill, Millward and Muspratt were eventually found after three weeks of hiding and, on their return to the ship, were flogged in two sessions with Churchill receiving a dozen lashes, and the others two dozen each. Churchill and his fellow deserters composed a letter hoping to appease Bligh on return to England and avoid possible fatal consequences on the result of a court martial. ''(Bligh refers to this letter in his reply to
Edward Christian's defence of his brother
Fletcher)'' == During the mutiny and Bligh's description ==