Panarella was born in 1925 in Brooklyn, New York. He is also known to have used January 5, 1922 as his birth date. He used the aliases Charles Panarello, Chas Esposito, John Garguilo, Joseph Charles Panarella and Charles "Moose" Panarella. He stood at tall, had brown eyes and a scar on his bottom lip. In 1940, Panarella was arrested for the first time. His criminal record included assault, burglary, extortion and possession of a loaded firearm. On August 11, 1972,
Albert Gallo, brother of the late rogue
Profaci crime family capo
Crazy Joe Gallo (killed on April 7, 1972), had pinpointed Joseph (The Yack) Yacovelli, Alphonse (Allie the Snake) Persico Sr.,
Gennaro Langella and at least one other Colombo hood (thought to be Panarella) at the bar of the Neapolitan Noodle located at 320 East 79th Street in
Midtown Manhattan. Minutes before the hit men arrived, however, the mobsters had moved to another table. In their place were five meat dealers from Chicago with their wives celebrating the engagement of one of their daughters to the restaurant's manager. As this party moved to a table, led by the wives, the shooter, dressed in casual clothes and wearing dark glasses and a long black shoulder length wig, opened up with two guns killing Sheldon Epstein and Max Tekelch and wounding two other men. The killer escaped and was never found. The public outrage was led by New York City Mayor
John V. Lindsay, who promised running the gangsters out of town. Panarella was unharmed. Panarella once allegedly forced a man to eat his own
testicles before killing him. Panarella survived several feuds within the Colombo family that killed more than 100 people. While in New York, Panarella had a large profitable crew that included
Gregory Scarpa Sr. The crew trafficked in
narcotics, robbed banks, and controlled
sheet metal and restaurant unions. ==Exile to Las Vegas==