Reception
Reviewing
The Virtues of the Prophet for the journal
Philosophy East and West in January 2010, Muhammad Ahsen notes that Upton (who is a
traditionalist) only makes passing reference to the
modern era, which the author describes as a source of evil, whereas the reviewer suggests that given the example set by the Prophet
Muhammad, the
Muslim has nothing to fear about modernity. The reviewer also queries Upton's "treatment of evil, with which the Commanding Self (
Nafs Ammara) seems to be equated." The reviewer instead suggests that we might look upon the Commanding Self – our human impulses – as "ethically and religiously neutral", "by themselves neither good nor evil". He is of the opinion that "Although rather alluring, these commentaries prolong the work unnecessarily. When combined with the Arabic and Morrow’s translation, the text becomes rather long-winded," and that, the sayings being "rather lengthy and advisory in nature, not to mention self-explanatory, there is little need to try and derive any esoteric meaning for them." Reacting to Upton's YouTube video entitled "The Psychic and Spiritual Dangers of AI", Carlos Perona Calvete wrote in
The European Conservative that "this video provides the most thorough understanding of AI and contemporary 'big data' crunching technology from a spiritual perspective I have encountered" and calling it "a delineation of relevant concepts so penetrating as to deserve canonical status in the analysis of, and resistance to, the denaturing developments of post-modern global civilization." ==Works==
Works
• Panic Grass (epic poem) City Lights Books, 1968; ASIN B001FSYIPE • Time Raid, (poems) Four Seasons Foundation, 1968; ASIN B0006BVUOS • Doorkeeper of the Heart, Versions of Rabi’a (poems), Threshold Books, 1988; Pir Press, 2004; • Hammering Hot Iron: A Spiritual Critique of Bly’s Iron John (metaphysics and social criticism), Quest Books, 1993; Sophia Perennis 2005; • The System of Antichrist: Truth and Falsehood in Postmodernism and the New Age (metaphysics and social criticism), Sophia Perennis, 2001; • Legends of the End: Prophesies of the End Times, Antichrist, Apocalypse, and Messiah from Eight Religious Traditions, Sophia Perennis, 2005; • Cracks in the Great Wall: UFOs and Traditional Metaphysics, Sophia Perennis, 2005; • ''The Virtues of the Prophet: A Young Muslim's Guide to the Greater Jihad, the War Against the Passions'', Sophia Perennis, 2006; • Knowings, in the Arts of Metaphysics, Cosmology and the Spiritual Path, Sophia Perennis, 2008; • Reflections of Tasawwuf: Essays, Poems and Narrative on Sufi Themes, Sophia Perennis, 2008; • Who Is the Earth? How to See God in the Natural World, Sophia Perennis, 2008; • Folk Metaphysics: Mystical Meanings in Traditional Folk Songs and Spirituals, Sophia Perennis, 2008 • Shadow of the Rose: The Esoterism of the Romantic Tradition (with his wife Jennifer Doane Upton), Sophia Perennis, 2008; • Findings in Metaphysic, Path and Lore, With a Response to the Traditionalist/Perennialist School, Sophia Perennis, 2010; • The Science of the Greater Jihad: Essays in Principal Psychology, Sophia Perennis, 2011; • ''The Wars of Love and Other Poems, with "A Reader's Guide to The Wars of Love" and "Lew Welch as Teacher"'', Sophia Perennis, 2011; • Vectors of the Counter-Initiation: The Course and Destiny of Inverted Spirituality, Sophia Perennis, 2012; • Day and Night on the Sufi Path, Sophia Perennis, 2015; • The Words of God to Prophet Muhammad: Forty Sacred Sayings, 2015; • What Poets Used to Know: Poetics, Mythopoesis, Metaphysics, Angelico Press/Sophia Perennis, 2016; • Dugin against Dugin: A Traditionalist Critique of the Fourth Political Theory, Reviviscimus, 2018; • The Alien Disclosure Deception: The Metaphysics of Social Engineering, Sophia Perennis, 2021; • The Way Forward for Perennialism, After the Antinomianism of Frithjof Schuon, Sophia Perennis, 2022; • Giving Myself Away: From Beat Protégé to Metaphysical Social Critic, a Cultural History of America through Fifty Years of Spiritual Seeking, Angelico Press, 2025; (paper); (cloth) Editor • Because You Talk: An Anthology of Bay Area Poets ed. Charles Upton, Robert Starfire, Hans Steinkellner, Other Voices Literary Society, 1976; • ''Dark Way to Paradise: Dante's Inferno in Light of the Spiritual Path'',Jennifer Doane Upton, Sophia Perennis, 2005; • False Dawn: The United Religions Initiative, Globalism and the Quest for a One-World Religion, Lee Penn, Sophia Perennis, 2005; • ''The Ordeal of Mercy: Dante's Purgatorio in Light of the Spiritual Path'', Jennifer Doane Upton, Angelico Press/Sophia Perennis, 2015; Anthologies • Because You Talk: An Anthology of Bay Area Poets ed. Charles Upton, Robert Starfire, Hans Steinkellner, Other Voices Literary Society, 1976; • Mark in Time, Glide Publications, 1971; • Excerpt from Panic Grass in City Lights Pocket Poets Anthology, Lawrence Ferlinghetti (ed.), City Lights Books, 1995; • Diamond Cutters: Visionary Poets in America, Britain and Oceania, Andrew Harvey and Jay Ramsay (ed.), Tayen Lane Publications, 2016; (hardcover), (paperback) Journal articles • ==See also==