Shortly after Chelo opened at Dame Collective in 2023, Contreras was named Chef of the Year by
Eater Portland. The website's Janey Wong wrote in part, "Even for folks who haven't had the chance to visit Chelo, Contreras is ubiquitous in the fabric of Portland's food scene — she's a staple at many of the city's biggest food events, her condiment line is stocked at fine food markets around town, and she's a vocal advocate for the trans community." In 2025, the website's Krista Garcia and Zoe Baillargeon included Chelo in overviews of Portland's best Mexican and best new restaurants and food carts, respectively. Katherine Chew Hamilton of
Portland Monthly included Chelo's chilaquiles rellenos in a list of the city's ten best dishes of 2023. The magazine's
Karen Brooks called the menu "playful" and Victoria Leandra of
HuffPost called the food "nostalgic, yet innovative". ==See also==