Washington Spirit (2016–2020) Matthews was drafted by
Washington Spirit in the 1st round of the
2016 NWSL College Draft. She signed with the Spirit in April 2016. In her rookie season, Matthews played in 17 regular season games, 8 starts, totaling 779 minutes and scored three goals. The Georgia native scored her first professional goal on 31 July 2016 against
Sky Blue FC. The team went on to make its first-ever
NWSL Championship appearance, ultimately losing on penalties to
Western New York Flash. Matthews dressed but served as an unused substitute. The Spirit would struggle in the
2017 season but Matthews became a regular contributor making 21 appearances and scoring 5 goals (tied for second on the team). Matthews sat out the
2018 season due to pregnancy. Ahead of the
2020 season, the Spirit announced that Matthews would be taking a paid leave of absence to focus on her family situation, notably the potential for her husband,
Jordan Matthews, to relocate within the
NFL. The paid leave was anticipated to last until May of the year and stipulated that Matthews could continue her career elsewhere, if necessary. In October 2020, Matthews was placed on the NWSL Re-Entry Wire by the Spirit.
Racing Louisville FC (2021–2022) In November 2020, Matthews was selected off the NWSL Re-Entry Wire by
Racing Louisville FC.
Chicago Red Stars She signed with
Chicago Red Stars in March 2023. On October 13, 2023, Matthews announced her retirement from professional football. ==International career==