Early career Bender debuted in the major leagues in 1903. He is one of only a few pitchers in the 20th century to throw 200 or more innings at the age of 19. His walks per nine innings rate were 2.17; only a few pitchers since 1893 have had a rate below 2.2 at the age of 20 or younger. That year, he also won a game against
Cy Young and met his future wife Marie. In 1905, Bender earned an 18–11
win–loss record with a 2.83 ERA, helping the A's win the AL pennant; but they lost the World Series in five games to the
New York Giants. Bender went 1–1 with a 1.06 ERA in the series, pitching a 4-hit, 3–0 complete-game shutout in Game 2, striking out 9. He went the distance again in Game 5, giving up just two earned runs in eight innings, losing 2–0 to
Christy Mathewson. After solid seasons in 1906 (15–10, 2.53), 1907 (16–8, 2.05), 1908 (8–9 despite a 1.75 ERA), and 1909 (18–8, 1.66), he led the Athletics to the AL pennant in 1910, as Philadelphia went 102–48, games ahead of the second-place
New York Highlanders. Bender led the AL in winning percentage, at .821, going 23–5 with a 1.58 ERA. He went 1–1 with a 1.93 ERA in the
World Series as the A's beat the
Chicago Cubs, who had gone 104–50 in the regular season, in five games. Bender pitched a complete-game three-hitter in the opener, striking out 8 and giving up only one unearned run. He lost Game 4 of the series in another complete-game effort, 4–3 in 10 innings. Bender pitched all innings for the Athletics, striking out 6.
Later career In 1911, he led the AL in winning percentage again (.773), going 17–5 with a 2.16 ERA as the A's won their second consecutive AL pennant, going 101–50 and finishing games ahead of the
Detroit Tigers. In a rematch of the
1905 World Series, the Athletics got their revenge, defeating the New York Giants and becoming the first American League team to win back-to-back World Series (the Chicago Cubs from the NL had won back-to-back titles in 1907 and 1908). After losing the opener 2–1 to Mathewson, though pitching a complete game, giving up just 5 hits and 2 runs (1 earned run) and striking out 11, Bender returned in Game 4, beating the Giants 4–2 on a complete game 7-hitter, and closed out the Series in game 6 with a 13–2 A's victory. Bender again went the distance (his 3rd complete game of the series), a 4-hit performance which he gave up no earned runs (the two Giants runs were unearned). He went 2–1, with 1.04 ERA and 3 complete games in the series. In 1912 Bender was 13–8 with a 2.74 ERA. He did not start for nearly 40 games late in the year and was suspended by the A's in September for alcohol abuse. His next contract had a clause saying he had to abstain from drinking to earn his full salary. In 1913, he went 21–10 with a 2.21 ERA, helping the A's win their third AL pennant in four years. They would also make it three World Series titles in four years by defeating the Giants in five games. Bender went 2–0 in the series with complete-game victories in Games 1 and 4. He led the AL in winning percentage (.850) for the third time in 1914, going 17–3 with a 2.26 ERA, and the A's would win their fourth AL pennant in five years. But the Athletics would be swept by the underdog
Boston Braves, with Bender losing Game 1 7–1, giving up 6 earned runs in innings. It was the only World Series game he failed to finish, after completing his previous nine starts in the Fall Classic. ,
Jack Coombs and
Rube Oldring — were featured in the
Thanhouser Company film,
The Baseball Bug (1911)When the
Baltimore Terrapins of the upstart
Federal League offered Bender a large salary increase, Athletics manager
Connie Mack knew he could not hope to match it and released Bender. In his only season with the Terrapins, Bender went 4–16, and his 3.99 ERA was near the bottom of the league. Bender later regretted leaving Philadelphia for the upstart league. After two years with the
Philadelphia Phillies, he left baseball in 1918 to work in the shipyards during World War I. Bender was an adept hitting pitcher in his major league career, posting a .212
batting average (243-for-1,147) with 102
runs, 6
home runs and 116
RBI. Bender notably hit two home runs in one game—rare for the dead ball era—in a 1906 game where he replaced outfielder
Topsy Hartsel. He had 10 or more RBI in a season four times, with a career-high 16 in 1910.
Minor leagues In 1919, Bender pitched in the minor leagues for the
Richmond Colts of the
Virginia League. He earned a 29–2 record that year. He spent the next three seasons as a player-manager: the first two seasons with the
New Haven Weissmen/Indians and the third was with the Class AA
Reading Aces. For the 1920 New Haven team, Bender recorded 25 wins as a pitcher. His record declined to 13–7 in 1921 and 8–13 in 1922. In 1923 and 1924, Bender did not manage, but did pitch for the minor league
Baltimore Orioles and the
New Haven Profs, respectively. He went 6–3 with a 5.03 ERA for Baltimore, then went 6–4 with a 3.07 ERA for New Haven. In 1931, he coached for the Giants and the next year managed the Yankees affiliate in the Central League. He then returned to the Athletics where he worked as a scout, minor league manager, and coach. The Yankees signed Bender in February 1942 as a pitching coach for the
Newark Bears. ==Personal life==