Catholicism The
Catholic Church opposes active euthanasia and
physician-assisted suicide on the grounds that life is a gift from God and should not be prematurely shortened. However, the church allows dying people to refuse
extraordinary treatments that would minimally prolong life without hope of recovery, a form of passive euthanasia. Western opinions against suicide among the sick were near-uniform until the mid-19th century, though Catholic thinker
Thomas More may have been a notable exception. In
Utopia, More appears to advocate for active euthanasia (though the specific term did not exist at the time), but some scholars have questioned whether More's position was serious or satirical. In the early modern period, Catholic theologians considered moral questions pertaining to refusing medical treatment and passive dying.
Francisco de Vitoria argued that a person does not violate the obligation to protect and preserve life if they choose not to take medicine prescribed by a doctor.
Domingo Báñez distinguished between ordinary means of preserving life, such as eating and procuring clothing, and extraordinary means, such as painful medical procedures. He asserted that while one is morally obligated to eat and cloth oneself, one is not morally obligated to undergo the amputation of a limb to save one's life.
John de Lugo contended that while one must use ordinary means to preserve life, one is not obligated to use ordinary means with no hope of benefit. He also maintained that there is a clear moral distinction between actively killing oneself and allowing death to occur naturally by refusing burdensome treatments.
Pope Pius XII was a vocal critic of euthanasia in the 1940s, but in 1957, he wrote "The Prolongation of Life: An Address of Pope Pius XII to an International Congress of Anesthesiologists" in which he declared that physicians did not have an obligation to prolong patients' lives with extraordinary treatments, such as providing
ventilator support for patients without hope of recovery. Historian
Ian Dowbiggin notes that this permits
passive euthanasia in some circumstances without violating Christian doctrine. On 5 May 1980, the
Vatican Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued the
Declaration on Euthanasia, condemning euthanasia as a "violation of the divine law, an offense against the dignity of the human person, a crime against life, and an attack on humanity". It noted that advances in medical technology had blurred the line between ordinary and extraordinary means of sustaining life, but allowed terminally ill patients to refuse life-prolonging treatment in situations in which a physician believes the treatment's harm would outweigh the benefit. On 22 September 2020, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith issued the letter "Samaritanus bonus", restating the church's opposition to euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide, criticising end-of-life protocols such as
do-not-resuscitate orders, urging Catholic hospitals and health-care workers not to engage in "plainly immoral conduct", including referring patients to other hospitals where they might undergo euthanasia, and accusing lawmakers who approved of euthanasia of being "accomplices of a grave sin". However, the letter also repeated the church's allowance for terminally ill patients to refuse life-extending treatments.
Reuters noted that the letter did not alter church doctrine, but instead reiterated existing doctrines in stronger language at a time when governments around the world, including those of some traditionally Catholic countries, were liberalising end-of-life care options.
Evangelical-Lutheranism The
Evangelical-Lutheran Churches teach that "Anything which aims for the death of those who suffer is murder, which God strictly prohibits in His Law."
Methodism The
United Methodist Church has eschewed euthanasia, holding that “the taking of a life” is “an offense against God’s sole dominion over life, and abandonment of hope and humility before God, and an affront to the dignity of and the solidarity among human beings.”
Eastern Orthodoxy The
Orthodox Church in America, along with other Eastern Orthodox Churches, also opposes euthanasia, stating that it must be condemned as murder stating that, "Euthanasia is the deliberate cessation to end human life."
Christian groups in support of euthanasia Groups claiming to speak for Christians rather than the official viewpoints of the Christian clergy have sprung up in a number of countries. ==Hinduism==