Having the full resources of the BBC, Walton was able to write for a large orchestra. The music is scored for three flutes, three oboes, three clarinets, three bassoons, four horns, three trumpets, three trombones, tuba and percussion comprising timpani, side drum, cymbals, tambourine, castanets, bass drum and gong. Walton held firm views about incidental music for plays, films and broadcasts: "film music is not good film music if it can be used for any other purpose ... the music should never be heard without the film". He had approached
Christopher Columbus music as not "in any way different from a rather superior film". Asked to allow any of the music to be published, he responded, "I can't believe that there is anything worth resuscitating from that vast and boring score". In 1974 he was again asked about the possible publication of Beatriz's song, "When Will He Return?". The critic Gillian Widdicombe, having heard the rebroadcast of the 1942 production, urged him to publish the song, saying it was "really beautiful". Walton responded, "If it was as beautiful as all that I should remember it", but he agreed to let it be published. After Walton's death the musicologist
Christopher Palmer arranged a three-movement suite from Walton's incidental music. The movements are: • Fiesta (chorus and orchestra, and then purely orchestral): A royal procession passes in triumph through the streets; crowds cheer and drums and trumpets sound. Columbus looks forward to the day of his return to Spain having done what "cannot be done". • Romanza: (
mezzo-soprano and orchestra): Beatriz sings sadly of her love for Columbus who is too focused on his ambitions to return her love as she would wish. • Gloria (tenor, chorus and orchestra}: Columbus, having discovered the New World, returns to Spain and is greeted as a hero. In 1988
Carl Davis arranged music from
Christopher Columbus as a
cantata, for
mezzo-soprano, tenor,
baritone, chorus and orchestra. In 2005
Chandos Records released a recording containing all of Walton's music for the play with an abbreviated version of MacNeice's words.
Richard Hickox conducts the BBC National Chorus of Wales and the BBC National Orchestra of Wales.
Julian Glover speaks Columbus's lines. ==Critical reception==