The production's designs attempted to imitate traditional Chinese theatre, ironically with
sumo wrestlers (one the son of
Man Mountain Dean) grappling onstage during intermission to entertain the audience. Director
Albert Marre cast
Yiddish theatre stars
Menasha Skulnik and
Molly Picon as Chu Chem and Rose,
Marcia Rodd as Lotte, and
James Shigeta as Prince Eagle. Other cast members included
Yuki Shimoda,
Robert Ito,
Reiko Sato,
Alvin Ing,
Haruki Fujimoto, as well as
choreographer Jack Cole who took on the role of Mongol Lord Hoo Hah. During rehearsals Picon, upset that her role had been reduced, walked out, but eventually returned. The November 1966 tryout at the New Locust Theatre in
Philadelphia was plagued by constant revisions to the script and score, and an unhappy Picon quit permanently. At one point on opening night, her successor Henrietta Jacobson turned to the audience and announced, "There was a song here, but you'll be better off without it." The reviews were brutal, with one critic describing it "like
blintzes and
soy sauce" and suggesting "a better title might be
The King and Oy." Co-producers Leigh and
Cheryl Crawford immediately cancelled the scheduled
Broadway opening at the
George Abbott Theatre. Unwilling to leave well enough alone, Allen and Leigh decided to revive the show 22 years later at the Jewish Repertory Theatre in
Manhattan. The greatly revamped version eliminated the play-within-a-play concept and the role of Rose, placed greater emphasis on the romance between Lotte and the prince, and revised the score. Encouraged by a favorable review from the third-string
New York Times critic, the creative team decided to move it uptown. The Broadway production, directed and choreographed by
Albert Marre, opened on March 17, 1989 at the
Ritz Theatre where, hampered by a no-name cast (Emily Zacharias as Lotte, Mark Zeller as Chu Chem, and Thom Sesma as the prince) and poor-to-dreadful reviews, it ran for only 68 performances, continuing for two months at heavy losses in the hope it would garner some
Tony Award nominations in a season beset by bad musicals (
Carrie,
Legs Diamond). When it was shut out, the production closed, a two-time flop in musical theatre history. ==Song list==