The
Domesday Book mentions the settlement of Bainton as having one priest, though there is no mention of a church. The south-west corner of the chancel dates back to 1280, and it is possible that parts date back to the late 12th century/early 13th century. Apart from the Domesday notation about a priest, the first allocation of a named priest (Peter de St Flovier), is recorded in 1229. The main body of the church is thought to date back to the late 1330s/early 1340s, as a result of the preceding church being ransacked by Scottish raiders after the
Battle of Byland in 1332. The dates for the building of the church can be accurately proved as it was recorded during the building phase that the clerk of Bainton was crushed when a pulley system failed, killing him. The west tower dates back to the main fabric of the church (14th century), and has a four-light window with hood mould. The second stage has a slit window, and the top of the tower has battlements with crosses pierced through the stones. The top of the tower used to have a spire of an octagonal shape which fell off during a storm in 1715. The remains of the spire were removed from the tower's roof in 1886. The church consists of a nave with north and south aisles, a chancel, and porches on the north and south side. Renovations were carried out in the 1820s, something which
Stephen Glynne describes as being in "...at some expense and in good spirit for the date." The whole of the east wall was pulled down in 1869 and then rebuilt during the extensive renovations carried out between 1866 and 1869 by
James Fowler. Glynne notes that there is no clerestory, and the roof of the nave must have been lowered during one of these renovations as there is a mark in the east wall of the tower showing where a higher-pitched roof existed. The font is thought to be
Norman in origin and dates from between 1130 and 1140, thus predating the current church; it has a cylindrical bowl, sculptured lozenges, a chevroned rim, and it set upon two steps. Not long after the restoration of the early 1920s, a great storm and flood caused damage to the church; one of the pinnacles of the tower crashed down and fell through the roof of the church in January 1926 on account of the high winds. The East Window was installed in 1951, and shows a baby Jesus with St Andrew and St Peter, a crucifixion scene, the good shepherd with his sheep, and the feeding of the 5,000. The original window, an 1844 design by
William Wailes, was damaged in 1941. The final part of the restoration was in 2016, and was a complete rebuild of the organ, which had last been played in 1986. Edmund de Mauley was a noble in the local area who was described as being a "great
pluralist", but was also notable for being killed at the
Battle of Bannockburn when he was in a charge near to the Bannock Burn and he was drowned. His tomb is on the south side of the church. There is a brass memorial to Sir Roger Godeale, a former priest of the church, which is surrounded by a Latin inscription. Ollard theorises that the brass was moved (it is in the centre of the chancel) during renovations in the 1840s. The memorial to a former rector (Robert Faucon) has caused intrigue as it carries his death year (but no day or month) as 1640, however he is recorded as dying in 1661. The church is dedicated to St Andrew, with the building being a grade I listed structure and is also part of Bainton Conservation area. Pevsner described it as an "..impressive church [that was]..such a change from those
Early English parish churches...". The rectory's coach house and stables are also listed buildings. == Parish and clergy ==