Circle of Two received mostly negative reviews at the time of its release. Terry Kelleher, writing in the
Miami Herald, gave the film one star out of four stating that it "lives down to expectations" and was critical of its cinematography and Burton's performance. ''
Leonard Maltin's Movie Guide'' states that "Burton is OK, and Dassin does not go for the cheap thrill, but the result is slight and forgettable." From
People magazine's "Picks and Pans Review": Richard Burton has carried a film or two in his day, and he tries to tote this one along. Burton, 56, plays a Toronto artist whose muse and passion are revived by a liaison with Tatum O’Neal, 18, a schoolgirl who wants to be a writer. The premise is within reason, if barely. It’s harder to accept the obnoxious supporting characters—her parents and friends, his art world associates—and the actors who play them quite badly. Jules (
Never on Sunday) Dassin’s direction and Thomas Hedley’s script are strained too. At one point O’Neal goes on a hunger strike when her parents won’t let her see Burton. “That old gentleman happens to mean more to me than anything else,” she wails. “The next time I eat, it will be with him.” While she’s a decent actress, O’Neal hardly seems attractive enough for the role, even though she records her first nude scene. Burton, meanwhile, gentlemanly underacts, yet his glances and monosyllables are so much more interesting than the rest of the movie they become a form of upstaging. In his review of
Chris Williams'
"The Richard Burton Diaries" for
Commentary, critic
Terry Teachout notes that this film was considered a low point in Burton's long, once-esteemed career:As Burton grew older, his roles, with few exceptions, grew tawdrier, and he became known, like
Laurence Olivier, for his willingness to do anything for money. He stooped so low in 1981 as to appear in Jules Dassin’s
Circle of Two, in which he plays a 60-year-old artist who falls for the 16-year-old Tatum O’Neal. By the time of his death three years later, his artistic reputation was in tatters. ==References==