Early career Carlisle was inspired to become a footballer by his father, Mervin, who played semi-professionally for
Morecambe and
Southport. Carlisle signed a professional contract with the club on 13 August 1997 and moved into the first-team squad. His single goal of the campaign came in a 3–1 victory over
Stoke City at the
Victoria Ground. He scored on his 93rd and final league appearance for the club in a 1–1 draw with
Oldham Athletic at
Boundary Park.
Queens Park Rangers Dowie recommended Carlisle to Queens Park Rangers
manager Gerry Francis, who paid a transfer fee of £250,000 to sign him on 25 May 2000. While he was out of action, Queens Park Rangers suffered relegation to the Second Division after finishing 23rd in the league. Soon after the injury he
attempted suicide, and years later was diagnosed with
major depressive disorder. Upon his return to football, Carlisle was injured again in a reserve-team match against
Bristol City, sparking fears that he had aggravated his previous injury. Upon his return to the team, Carlisle won the Second Division Player of the Month award for November 2003. He scored one goal in 39 matches in
2003–04 as Queens Park Rangers finished as runners-up in the league, achieving promotion to the
Championship. Carlisle's contract with Queens Park Rangers ended at the conclusion of the 2003–04 campaign.
Leeds United In June 2004, Carlisle agreed to join recently relegated Championship club
Leeds United on a
free transfer. His contract with Leeds began on 1 July 2004, When fit again, Carlisle found it difficult to break into the first team as his place in the centre of defence had been taken by
Matthew Kilgallon. His return came on 28 December 2004, when he was brought on as an 80th-minute substitute for
Frazer Richardson in the 2–1 win against
Plymouth Argyle. At the end of the 2004–05 campaign it was revealed that two clubs,
Watford and Stoke City, were both competing to sign Carlisle. Leeds United accepted bids of £100,000 from both clubs but Carlisle chose to sign for Watford, and he agreed a three-year contract with the club on 5 August 2005.
Watford and Luton Town Watford manager
Aidy Boothroyd, who had been a
coach at Leeds during the previous season, was pleased with the signing, stating that Carlisle was "exactly the type of defender I wanted". Soon after, Carlisle scored two goals in a competitive match for the first time in his career, grabbing both in Watford's 2–1 win against
Wolverhampton Wanderers in the
second round of the League Cup. However, the referee did not show Carlisle a red or yellow card during the match, and no further action was taken against the player. During the 2005–06 campaign, Carlisle made 35 appearances and scored five goals, helping Watford to achieve a place in the play-offs after finishing third in the Championship. However, towards the end of the season he suffered yet another injury, being forced off the pitch in Watford's penultimate league match away at Queens Park Rangers. The thigh problem caused him to be unavailable for the
play-offs as Watford defeated Leeds 3–0 at the Millennium Stadium to win promotion to the
FA Premier League. The injury forced Carlisle to miss the first eight months of the
2006–07 Premier League season, and he eventually returned to full training in February 2007. He played in two reserve team matches for Watford in order to regain some fitness, hoping to break into the first team and make his Premier League debut. On 2 March 2007, Carlisle joined local rivals
Luton Town on a one-month emergency
loan deal in an attempt to return to full match fitness. He made his debut for Luton the following day in the 3–2 away defeat to Wolverhampton Wanderers in the Championship, coming on as a substitute for
Matthew Spring, who had himself joined the club from Watford earlier in the season after failing to break into the first team. Carlisle went on to play five matches for Luton. Watford were defeated 4–1 at
Villa Park.
Burnley and loan spells forward
Tamás Priskin in 2008|alt=A striker in a white and navy blue soccer strip has the ball. The defender, wearing a claret strip, attempts to make the tackle. On 14 August 2007,
Steve Cotterill, manager of fellow Championship club Burnley, made an offer of £200,000 for Carlisle, who signed a three-year contract at
Turf Moor two days later. Helped along by the club captain
Steven Caldwell, Carlisle settled in well at Burnley. Two days after signing, he made his debut for his new club in the 2–0 defeat away to
Scunthorpe United. On 28 September 2007, the day before a Championship match, he was involved in a serious car crash after spinning and crashing into a ditch causing his car to be
written off. Steve Cotterill praised Carlisle's character for playing the next day in the 1–1 draw with
Crystal Palace. His partnership with Caldwell was broken towards the end of the campaign as Carlisle was given suspensions after being sent off twice in his last four matches of the season, first in the 1–2 loss to Preston and then in the last match of the season, a 0–5 defeat at Crystal Palace. Carlisle ended the
2007–08 season with two goals in 35 appearances. He remained out of the team for the whole of February 2009. Prior to the start of the campaign, Carlisle stated his belief that Burnley could avoid relegation back to the Championship. He was selected in the team to play Burnley's first top-flight match in 33 years on 15 August 2009, when the team were defeated 2–0 by Stoke City at the
Britannia Stadium. During the early part of the season, he formed a defensive pairing with new signing
André Bikey. After over a month out of the Burnley team with the injury, he made his first start under new manager
Brian Laws in the 1–0 defeat to
Bolton Wanderers on 26 January 2010. Although the team was relegated from the Premier League at the end of the season, Carlisle was one of several players offered a new contract, and he signed a two-year extension in May 2010. In the first away match of the
2010–11 season, he scored an injury-time equaliser against
Ipswich Town; the goal was Burnley's first from a
corner kick for 15 months. After serving a three-match suspension in October 2010 following a red card in the 1–1 draw away at
Millwall, Carlisle returned to the team for the League Cup tie against
Aston Villa and scored an 89th-minute equaliser to take the match to extra time. Carlisle made his Preston debut in the opening match of the campaign, a 4–2 home defeat against Colchester on 6 August 2011. He was a regular starter for Preston during the opening months of the season and also played in the cup competitions as the team reached the
third round of the League Cup before being eliminated by Southampton and progressed to the
same stage of the Football League Trophy with
penalty shoot-out victories over Morecambe and
Rochdale. Preston manager
Phil Brown brought in
Jamie McCombe on loan as cover for Carlisle, and the
Huddersfield Town loanee kept his place in the starting line-up throughout December 2011. Carlisle returned to the Preston team for the visit to Rochdale on 2 January 2012, when he was selected to play alongside
Craig Morgan by caretaker managers
Graham Alexander and
David Unsworth. Later the same day, Carlisle signed for
League Two club
Northampton Town, managed by former Watford boss Aidy Boothroyd, on loan for the remainder of the season. He made his first start for Northampton in the 1–0 win over
AFC Wimbledon at the
Sixfields Stadium on 14 February 2012. He scored his first goal for the team in the 3–1 home defeat to
Bradford City on 14 April 2012.
York City and Northampton Town return in 2012 Carlisle signed for newly promoted League Two club
York City on 30 August 2012 on a contract lasting until January 2013, having previously turned down a contract offer from Northampton. He made his debut two days later in York's 3–1 victory at home to
Oxford United. He made his second debut the following day in Northampton's 3–0 home win over
Morecambe. He played for Northampton in their 3–0 defeat to Bradford in the
2013 League Two play-off final at Wembley Stadium on 18 May 2013. ==International career==